Agent
AJ Faigin
AJ Faigin Career Overview
Landmark contract negotiations and roster
AJ Faigin built a reputation in professional football for inventing aggressive representation strategies prior to the advent of modern free agency. His client list featured a quartet of Pro Football Hall of Fame enshrinees: Mel Blount, Jack Lambert, Mike Webster, and Jim Kelly. Collectively, these gridiron stars earned various opening-round draft selections, earned abundant Pro Bowl invitations, and captured eight Super Bowl championships.
His most complex maneuvers surrounded Buffalo Bills selection Jim Kelly starting in 1983. Faigin guided Kelly to the Houston Gamblers of the USFL, creating the first instance of an opening-round NFL draftee jumping to the rival league via a record-setting deal. Amid antitrust battles between both leagues, Faigin and partner Greg Lustig conferred with Donald Trump, who sought Kelly for an eventual NFL team. After Faigin warned of a lawsuit unless Trump personally backed the financial terms against a league collapse, Trump agreed to sign, despite voicing his own legal threats. Faigin strategically disclosed the signed pact to reporters to pressure Buffalo management. Following discussions with USFL Chicago executive Bruce Allen, Faigin took a late-night flight to Toronto with league investors. Allen subsequently telephoned him inside the Bills headquarters during final negotiations. These tactics culminated in Kelly securing the most lucrative pact in NFL history, paying sixty percent beyond the compensation earned by Joe Montana, the second-best-paid athlete at that time.
During the 1982 players strike, Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker Jack Lambert brought Faigin's strategy paper, called A Modest Proposal, before a union strike ballot assembly. The document urged membership to demand open free agency instead of a wage scale based on longevity, though delegates declined to change course.
Faigin also engineered a supplemental draft loophole to steer University of Miami national champion passer Bernie Kosar to his preferred Cleveland Browns. That controversial tactic prompted threatened court actions from no fewer than five rival clubs. Kosar subsequently guided Cleveland into three AFC Championship matchups. Although Bernie Kosar Sr. gave him a verbal handshake commitment, Faigin never held the formal title of designated agent.
Legal and business career
Born in Cleveland, Ohio, on August 11, 1947, Faigin initially served as a trial lawyer in the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office handling homicides and other serious felonies throughout his twenties. An acquaintance from his university and legal studies later recruited him into Lustig Pro Sports to handle general counsel responsibilities. Faigin quickly transitioned into client recruitment and premier football contract bargaining before exiting the firm in 1987.
Moving to Chicago during the 1990s, he crafted curriculum and served as an instructor of Negotiation and Sports Law at Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago-Kent Law School. Faigin also stepped into national politics during the 1992 Bill Clinton presidential run, campaigning across New Hampshire and attending the Democratic National Convention. Eventually relocating to California, he established himself as an entrepreneur within the trade show and exposition sector.
Post-agency litigation
Despite leaving his sports firm in 1987, Faigin faced legal actions regarding financial shelters and investment counseling directed by firm founder Greg Lustig. A federal judge dismissed the allegations against Faigin as frivolous, penalizing Kelly's attorney $13,000 in sanctions and confirming Faigin took no part in player investment guidance. Faigin subsequently initiated a defamation lawsuit over statements published inside Kelly's memoir. He ultimately lost his appellate challenge when the appeals court upheld the trial judge's discretionary exclusion of the earlier sanctions ruling from jury review.
