Coach

Bob Allen

Shortstop Who Managed the Phillies and Reds

What he is remembered for

Bob Allen was a shortstop first and a manager second. He did lead two clubs, the Philadelphia Phillies and the Cincinnati Reds, but he held each position only briefly, so his name belongs mainly to the story of a player whose career took a short detour into the dugout. He died in Little Rock, Arkansas, in 1943.

The 1900 Reds season

The year that defines his time as a manager is 1900. The Reds gave him the job that year, the team ended up in seventh place, and the club dismissed him after that single season. Because he never got a second year, the campaign stands as his clearest chance to run a team, and it also explains why neither of his stints as a manager lasted. Nothing else in his record as a manager is documented as fully as this one season.

A playing manager

Allen did not confine himself to the bench. While running the Reds, he sometimes wrote his own name into the lineup at shortstop, the position he had played for years. He was a playing manager, willing to take the field himself instead of only giving directions from the sideline.

How his playing career unfolded

Robert Gilman Allen grew up in Marion, Ohio, and played youth baseball there. In the National League he played shortstop for three teams: the Reds, the Boston Beaneaters and the Philadelphia Phillies. His debut came with the Phillies. People regarded him as a power hitter, and his best single-season total was eight home runs.

Then came a pitch to the face that broke his cheekbone. His contract expired afterward, and he stepped away from baseball for three years before signing with the Beaneaters. As his playing time later dwindled, he left the game a second time. He came back as a manager, leading the Phillies first and the Reds after that.

The injury and its reputation

The broken cheekbone was not part of a season he managed, yet it colors how people recall his playing years. The Chicago Tribune reported that fragments of the shattered bone had entered his brain. The paper suggested he might have suffered permanent damage to his eyesight and mind.

Sources