Coach
Bob Ferguson
Baseball Pioneer, Player-Manager and League Official
Managing record and influence
Hartford gave Ferguson his strongest results as a manager, with the club placing third in each of its two National League seasons. Al Spalding watched how Ferguson handled those teams, and that impression explains why Spalding later brought Ferguson to Chicago as captain. Philadelphia's franchise, the Quakers long before it became the Phillies, had already had Ferguson as its first ever manager. Other managing posts followed in both the National League and the American Association, and Ferguson often kept playing while running the club. Away from the field, Ferguson held the presidency of National Association of Professional Base Ball Players for the entire life of the sport's first fully professional league. When Hartford entered the National League at its start, Ferguson additionally took a seat as one of that circuit's directors.
Career path
Brooklyn was where Ferguson grew up, and the career began there too, first with the Atlantics and then the Mutuals, at a time when baseball was still semi-professional. Catching for the Atlantics, Ferguson helped defeat the Cincinnati Red Stockings, the first club made up entirely of paid players, and that loss ended their long winning streak. Once the National Association got under way, the Mutuals named Ferguson their player-manager. Ferguson later went back to the Atlantics and stayed with them for several seasons of the league. For its last year, the Hartford Dark Blues hired Ferguson to manage, drawn by a reputation as baseball's most autocratic captain.
After the Association folded, Hartford opened its first National League season with Ferguson serving as a league director. When Hartford folded, the brand new Chicago White Stockings handed Ferguson the player-manager job, though only one season passed before it ended. The new Troy Trojans, who began play in the National League, then gave Ferguson the same role, and Ferguson held it until that team folded. The final two managerial posts came in the American Association. Ferguson served as player-manager of the Pittsburgh Alleghenys, who later became the Pirates, and also led the New York Metropolitans for parts of two seasons. Along the way, Ferguson worked as an umpire too.
Signature seasons
At the plate, one season stood above the rest. Ferguson ranked third in the league in batting average and tied for first in on-base percentage, while placing fourth in both runs batted in and hits.
Tension in Hartford reached a breaking point after a hard defeat by the Red Stockings, a game in which Ferguson himself committed several errors. Tommy Bond, the pitcher, hinted that Ferguson was crooked. Bond retracted the remark almost at once and blamed his own anger, after Ferguson rejected the accusation. Bond later asked for a release because playing under Ferguson was beyond him. Morgan Bulkeley, the league president and a former Dark Blues owner, approved that request.
Chicago went poorly. The White Stockings finished with an even record, and in Spalding's memoirs Ferguson comes across as tactless and with no feel for handling men.
With the Quakers, Ferguson lost command early. The team had been struggling when it traveled to Providence to meet the Grays. Hoping to draw local fans, Ferguson named Rhode Island native Art Hagan to pitch. The plan backfired. Hagan surrendered a huge number of runs, the Quakers made many errors behind Hagan, and the team never scored. The decision made financial sense, yet it turned into a public relations disaster. People branded Ferguson a sadist for leaving Hagan in the game.
Coaching style
Domineering and dictatorial as a captain, Ferguson demanded obedience and had a violent streak. Ferguson expected the men to follow without question, and after one season several of them were forced out amid heavy gambling rumors surrounding the team. A temper flared frequently, even during victories. According to the Chicago Tribune, Ferguson would swear at whoever committed an error for Hartford. More than once, people heard Ferguson publicly threaten second baseman Jack Burdock. Some players put up with this, while others would not go along with it. Tom Carey, the shortstop, and Jack Remsen, the center fielder, shouted back without hesitation, and pitcher Candy Cummings sulked often.
In Chicago, an overbearing manner did nothing to improve discipline. The team split, and players squabbled among themselves. Spalding wrote that Ferguson relied on force rather than strategy. Cap Anson eventually took over the role. One suggested explanation for the struggles was that players did not want to emulate Ferguson's personality. Stubbornness and a bad temper caused trouble at times, and many people disliked Ferguson.
Legacy
No one questioned Ferguson's personal character. Observers regarded Ferguson as honest and upstanding during a period when gamblers and rowdy players and fans had badly damaged baseball's image. Near the end of Ferguson's time as a league official, Ferguson joined in a landmark ruling. Louisville Grays pitcher Jim Devlin asked for his freedom, saying Louisville had not met the terms of its contract. Ferguson and the other league directors sided with Grays vice-president Charles Chase and ordered Devlin to stay. The following season, Devlin and three teammates, Bill Craver, George Hall and Al Nichols, were suspended for life for throwing games. Devlin spent years seeking reinstatement and never got it.
Ferguson also earns credit as baseball's first switch-hitter, batting from either side of the plate. Switch-hitting caught on slowly, but managers came to see its advantages, many players began experimenting, and it led toward what is now called platooning. The nickname Death to Flying Things, though well known, is spurious. It comes from a mistake in the Baseball Encyclopedia's 1969 edition.
People remember Ferguson's generosity as well. Atlantics left fielder Al Thake drowned while fishing near Fort Hamilton in New York Harbor, and Ferguson arranged a benefit game on Thake's behalf.
