Coach
Butch Davis
Head Coach Profile
Coaching record and impact
Before he took on the expansion Cleveland Browns, Butch Davis had turned Miami into a national power. Between 1995 and 2000 the Miami Hurricanes compiled a 51 and 20 record under Davis. The last of those teams went 11 and 1, and both human polls ranked it second. Even so, Miami did not get to play for the national championship at the 2001 Orange Bowl, because the Bowl Championship Series formula contained a quirk that worked against it. Beating top-ten opponents earned extra credit under the BCS, and the system later added bonus points for quality wins. Florida State got the invitation instead, though Miami had beaten the Seminoles that year in a game decided when a last-second field goal sailed wide right. Oklahoma went on to beat Florida State 13 to 2 in the Orange Bowl. The snub fueled Miami. The next season, with Larry Coker running the offense as coordinator, the program won its first undisputed national championship in two decades.
When Davis arrived in Cleveland in 2001, the Browns had won only five games over the two previous years combined. That first season finished 7 and 9. During year two, a pair of back-to-back close games, against the Baltimore Ravens and also the Atlanta Falcons, helped a 9 and 7 team reach the playoffs. Only two coaches have taken the expansion Browns to the postseason: Davis, and Kevin Stefanski in 2020. A Davis defense also led the league with 33 interceptions.
Career path
Davis was born in Tahlequah, Oklahoma. After earning all-state honors as a fullback and defensive end, Davis graduated from Bixby High School in 1970. At Arkansas, Davis played defensive end for the Razorbacks until a knee injury in the freshman year ended the playing days. Davis spent the rest of college as a student assistant.
The first coaching jobs came at high schools. Davis assisted at Fayetteville in 1973, at Pawhuska in 1974 and 1975, and at Charles Page in Sand Springs in 1976 and 1977. In 1978 Will Rogers High School gave Davis a first head coaching position.
A 15-year association with Jimmy Johnson began in 1979. Davis started out coaching receivers and tight ends at Oklahoma State, then moved to the defensive line at Miami, where the 1987 Hurricanes won the national title. Davis next followed Johnson to the Dallas Cowboys as defensive line coach. Johnson's first year, 1989, produced a 1 and 15 Cowboys team, and the staff went on to help win back-to-back Super Bowls under new owner Jerry Jones. Davis became defensive coordinator when Dave Wannstedt left in 1993. After Johnson departed, Davis remained in Dallas for one more year as an assistant under Barry Switzer.
Miami hired Davis as head coach in January 1995. The Cleveland job came next and ran from 2001 through 2004. Following a 3 and 8 start, Davis resigned in December 2004, leaving a 24 and 35 overall record with the Browns. On November 13, 2006, North Carolina athletic director Dick Baddour announced Davis as the new head coach, replacing John Bunting, who had been fired that October. Davis stayed at North Carolina from 2007 into the summer of 2011, and the tenure ended in dismissal amid a series of NCAA investigations. An advisory role with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers began for Davis in February 2012. Florida International University then made Davis its head coach in 2017, a return to head coaching.
Signature seasons
The 1995 Miami season showed Davis's resilience. Soon after Davis arrived, NCAA investigators concluded that the Hurricanes had committed several violations while predecessor Dennis Erickson was in charge. Miami finished 8 and 3 but could not play in the postseason, and the program lost 31 football scholarships spread over several years.
The 2002 Browns make up the other defining year. Davis's second season in Cleveland ended with a playoff berth, and the postseason game from that year fed a 2003 quarterback controversy between Tim Couch and backup Kelly Holcomb. Davis eventually gave the starting job to Holcomb, although Couch did start a few games. Before 2004, Davis signed Jeff Garcia and cut Couch. Bottlegate also happened during that first Cleveland year, an officiating episode that ranks among the NFL's most disputed ever.
North Carolina's 2007 team, the first under Davis, finished 4 and 8. Six of those losses came by a touchdown or less. Two of the setbacks were to opponents then sitting inside the top 15 nationally. The record was poor, yet the Tar Heels drew an average of 57,000 fans at Kenan Stadium, the highest average attendance of the Mack Brown era. The matchup with South Carolina pulled in 61,000, the second-largest crowd in school history. On November 21, 2007, Davis accepted an extension covering one more year, along with a raise to $291,000 annually.
Legacy
Jeremy Shockey, Reggie Wayne, Edgerrin James, Clinton Portis, Andre Johnson, Joaquin Gonzalez, Ed Reed and Ray Lewis all passed through Davis's program at Miami. In each of Davis's six seasons there, the American Football Coaches Association recognized the Hurricanes for outstanding graduation rates.
The North Carolina deal ran seven years and paid about $1.86 million each season, including a base salary of $286,000. Baddour said the school's board of trustees had approved a raise that would add $29,000 to the base salary, $5,000 in expenses and $100,000 in supplemental income. Davis also collected a $25,000 yearly expenses supplement. Educational Foundation payments from the Ram's Club began at $1 million in 2007 and climbed to $1.3 million in 2013.
At Florida International, Davis led the team to a bowl game in each of three consecutive seasons, from 2017 to 2019. The 2021 departure turned bitter. Shortly after the contract expired, Davis accused FIU administrators of deliberately undermining the football program.
