Coach
Christy Mathewson
Christy Mathewson, Big Six of the New York Giants
Overview
Christy Mathewson, the American pitcher known as Big Six, spent 17 Major League Baseball seasons, nearly all of them with the New York Giants, and earned a reputation as one of the most dominant arms the game has produced. Mathewson is listed at 1.85 m. Among the career leaders, Mathewson ranks with the ten best ever in wins, shutouts and earned run average, along with other major categories. In 1936 the Baseball Hall of Fame inducted Mathewson as one of its first five members.
Early years
Mathewson grew up in Factoryville, Pennsylvania, and attended Keystone Academy. When Mathewson was 14, the local manager asked for a start against a rival team, and that game launched a semiprofessional career. At Bucknell University, Mathewson served as class president and played football, basketball and baseball. Walter Camp named Mathewson to his 1900 All-American football team. Mathewson also played fullback in pro football, including a stint with the Pittsburgh Stars, but left that team midway through the 1902 season.
Path to the majors
Mathewson began professional baseball with the Taunton Herrings of the New England League, then moved to the Norfolk Phenoms of the Virginia League, where the season finished with a 20 and 2 record. Throughout this period Mathewson kept attending classes at Bucknell. In July 1900 the Giants bought the contract from Norfolk for $1,500. Mathewson appeared in six games for New York that summer and won none. The Giants, dissatisfied with the result, sent Mathewson back to Norfolk and demanded a refund. The Cincinnati Reds then claimed Mathewson off the Norfolk roster, but they quickly returned the pitcher to the Giants in a trade for Amos Rusie.
Pitching style
Mathewson's approach rested on a good fastball and outstanding control. The fadeaway, a screwball that Mathewson learned from teammate Dave Williams, served as the signature pitch. A Ken Burns documentary relates a story that credits Rube Foster instead, yet many historians regard that tale as apocryphal. Mathewson finished the career with 2,507 strikeouts and a 2.13 earned run average. Mathewson also handled the bat well, hitting .281 across 11 World Series games.
The 1903 contract episode
A salary four times the Giants figure lured Mathewson into a brief signing in 1903 with the Browns, the St. Louis club that played in the American League. Robert Lee Hedges, who owned the Browns, tore up the deal as his contribution to a settlement that brought peace after two years of fighting between the National and American Leagues. Hedges explained that peace mattered more than anything else, even if it effectively meant giving up a pennant.
Rise to the top
Mathewson became a premier pitcher between 1903 and 1905. In 1904 the Giants won their initial National League title, and Mathewson helped drive that success. No World Series took place that year, although John McGraw proclaimed the Giants the best team in the world. In 1905 catcher Roger Bresnahan worked closely with Mathewson, whose memory for the weaknesses of opposing hitters paved the way for a historic season. Mathewson won 31 games, threw shutouts eight times and walked only 64 batters. Adding a 1.28 earned run average to those numbers, Mathewson earned the Triple Crown by leading the National League in all three categories.
The 1905 World Series
The Giants beat the Philadelphia Athletics to claim the franchise's first World Series championship. Mathewson started three games and threw a shutout in each. Within a span of only six days, Mathewson shut out Philadelphia three times, going the distance in every start, and gave up just 14 hits in total. No pitcher has matched those three shutouts in a single World Series, and Mathewson also holds the career World Series record for shutouts with four.
Later seasons and rivalries
The following season, an early diphtheria diagnosis cost Mathewson some of that sharpness. Mathewson went 22 and 12 with a 2.97 earned run average, well above the league mark of 2.62. Pitching duels with Mordecai Three Finger Brown made Mathewson famous. Mathewson won 13 of their 25 meetings, Brown won 11, and one ended in a no-decision. Mathewson pitched for the Giants until 1916, and devout Christian beliefs kept Mathewson off the mound on Sundays.
War Service and death
During World War I Mathewson joined the Chemical Warfare Service, part of the United States Army. A training accident exposed Mathewson to chemical weapons. That exposure weakened the respiratory system and led to tuberculosis. Mathewson died at Saranac Lake, New York, in 1925.
