Coach
Harvey Johnson
A Football Lifer Whose Best Work Came North of the Border
The big picture
Johnson's reputation rests on a split verdict. Two stints leading the Buffalo Bills, one in the American Football League and one in the NFL, produced a 2-23-1 record, and that mark colors how Buffalo fans recall the coach. The Kitchener-Waterloo Dutchmen tell a very different story. Johnson held the posts of head coach and general manager there and collected four Ontario Rugby Football Union championships in four years. Nothing else on the résumé shines as brightly, and those titles show that Johnson could assemble and guide a winner.
The buffalo years
The Bills won the 1965 AFL Championship game while Johnson sat on their coaching staff. That victory ties Johnson's name to the best stretch of the franchise's early history and marks the high point of the Buffalo tenure. Eight years in the city as an assistant coach and defensive coordinator came first, before the top job opened up in 1968. Joe Collier was fired two games into that season, and Johnson took over as head coach. The Bills finished 1-10-1 under Johnson, and John Rauch replaced Johnson the following year. Johnson did not leave, though, and returned as defensive backfield coach for two seasons.
A second chance as head coach arrived in 1971 and went even worse. Buffalo finished 1-13, and once that season ended Johnson was moved to the scouting department. In practice, that reassignment closed the book on Johnson's head coaching career.
The playing days
Before any of that, Johnson was a player. A fullback at William & Mary, Johnson earned All-Southern Conference honors in 1941 and 1942. Service in the United States Navy came during World War II, and Johnson suited up for the 1944 Bainbridge Commodores in that period. Johnson then turned to placekicking. From 1946 until 1949, Johnson kicked for the New York Yankees in the All-America Football Conference. In 1951, another kicking job followed with the NFL's New York Yanks.
Early coaching and scouting
Johnson's coaching life started in 1953 with the Hamilton Tiger-Cats, where Johnson worked as a backfield coach. A year later came the Dutchmen job, which combined head coaching with general manager duties. After the 1957 season Johnson left Kitchener-Waterloo to serve as chief scout of the Montreal Alouettes.
Legacy
Born in 1919, Johnson is remembered as a player, a scout and a coach whose career crossed several leagues. Scouting stayed Johnson's job with the Bills until death in 1983. Some people speculated that a shared love of thoroughbred horse racing with owner Ralph Wilson helped explain why Johnson remained on the payroll despite the poor results. Whatever the reason, Johnson's name is bound up with the early history of the Bills, from the 1965 title game to two difficult head coaching stints. The Ontario titles with the Dutchmen remain the best evidence of what Johnson could do as a head coach.
