Coach
Heinie Smith
Buffalo Baseball Figure and Interim Manager of the Giants
The year that defined him
1902 stands as the most important year of Heinie Smith's career. The New York Giants made him their interim manager that season after John McGraw was replaced. Smith went 5 wins and 27 losses with the club. A record that poor suggests he inherited a team in transition, not a settled contender, and it remains the only measure of his time directing the Giants.
The same season produced his best work on the field. Smith set career highs in stolen bases, doubles, hits, RBIs, runs and games played. Few players post their top numbers and also take charge of the team in a single year, which makes 1902 unusual.
How he got there
Smith began as a second baseman. The Louisville Colonels and the Pittsburgh Pirates came first on his résumé. He then joined the New York Giants for 1901 and 1902, and he closed out his playing days with the Detroit Tigers in 1903. Because he was still on the Giants roster when the managing job came, people remember him as both a player and a manager.
Buffalo after the majors
Smith did not leave baseball once the majors were behind him. He settled in Buffalo and managed the Buffalo Bisons of the International League. In 1915 and 1916 he also coached the University of Buffalo baseball team. That work carried him from the professional ranks into the college game. He died in Buffalo, New York, in 1939, in the city where most of his later baseball work took place.
The heinie name
Heinie was a common German nickname in baseball at the start of the 20th century, and Smith was one of many players who went by it. Heinie Schuble, Heinie Beckendorf, Heinie Zimmerman, Heinie Groh and Heinie Manush are among the others who shared it.
Legacy
What sets Smith apart from those namesakes is a short stint leading the Giants, followed by years of managing and coaching in Buffalo.
