Documentary

Assault in the Ring

A Showtime Documentary on the Boxing Scandal That Ended Two Careers

The central reason to see it

Years after the punches were thrown, Assault in the Ring delivers its strongest moment. Luis Resto stops denying what he knew and apologizes for his part in the scheme. The Showtime documentary returns to a notorious night in 1983 at Madison Square Garden, when Resto earned a 10-round decision over Billy Collins Jr., an undefeated prospect. Someone had stripped padding from Resto's gloves. The fight sets the stage, but the confession is what keeps viewers watching.

Who took responsibility and who did not

At first Resto claimed the gloves were a mystery to him. Eric Drath ended that stance by putting a transcript of Resto's own police interview in front of him. Lewis never budged. He denied any wrongdoing and pointed the finger at Artie Curley, the cornerman responsible for wrapping Resto's hands. Plenty of Lewis's supporters have said someone else took the padding out, and Lewis clung to that claim of innocence until he died in 2020. The lesson for athletes is plain: you answer for whatever you permit in your corner.

What the film says about winning at any price

The documentary works best as a portrait of a sport in which victory becomes the only thing that matters. Fighters in the early 1980s trusted Panama Lewis without question, because many considered Lewis among the finest trainers around. Resto says Lewis crushed asthma pills and stirred the medicine into water, hoping to boost lung capacity and stamina over the rounds. Resto also claims Lewis had removed padding from gloves at least twice before. Eventually Resto conceded that he knew plaster had been used on his hand wraps, hardening them into casts.

A person chasing an edge tends to experience it as ordinary preparation, and the film shows how far that thinking can carry someone. Resto paid heavily, since the suspension of his license ended any chance of another fight. The film suggests that real toughness belongs to the man who finally looked squarely at his own actions, not to whoever landed the blows.

How the system let down the injured fighter

Collins left the ring with a torn iris and blurred vision, and those injuries finished his career. The commission declared him permanently ineligible to box. His side then sued the New York State Athletic Commission and lost, in part because the glove inspection had been so cursory. Collins died in a car accident in 1984, nine months after the bout. For fans, the point is that every fight rests on honest oversight.

The punishments

Following an October 1986 trial, Lewis received a six-year sentence and Resto a three-year one. Lewis walked out of prison in 1990. Once the case came to light, the state boxing license was taken from Lewis, and most states went along with that action. Even so, the film observes that Lewis held onto some standing within boxing while Resto was shunned. Footage even shows Lewis still turning up in professional settings in spite of the ban.

The era and the fighters around lewis

The story belongs to the early 1980s. Lewis trained a stable that included Aaron Pryor, the light-welterweight champion, who faced Alexis Arguello in 1982. That same year Lewis worked the corner of Roberto Duran, who lost to Wilfred Benitez. The Resto and Collins bout was an undercard fight, scheduled below Duran against Davey Moore.

Behind the camera

Eric Drath, a former boxing manager, directed and produced Assault in the Ring, which marked the debut of Drath as a documentary filmmaker. Showtime released it in English in 2008. Several boxers told Drath about the story, and he began by hoping to clear Resto's name, until the evidence steered the project somewhere else. The film covers the 1983 incident and what came after, including the Collins lawsuit, and it traces a long trip for Resto from the Bronx to Virginia, then through Miami and on to Nashville. In 2010 it took home a Sports Emmy Award in the category of Outstanding Sports Documentary.

Sources