Documentary

Dennis Rodman's Big Bang in Pyongyang

Dennis Rodman in Pyongyang: When Celebrity Diplomacy Collapsed on Camera

The main lesson

Fame and a huge ego give nobody the tools for politics. A British documentary makes that point by tracking Dennis Rodman as Rodman leads former NBA players to Pyongyang for an exhibition game scheduled around Kim Jong Un's birthday. When the cameras start rolling, the whole trip unravels. Viewers get something funny, sad and uncomfortable, and it prompts a question: what does a famous athlete owe the people who follow them into a risky situation?

When the host becomes the problem

In effect, the film shows what a winning mindset is not. Rodman hosts the project and pushes it forward, with financing from Paddy Power, and this was Rodman's third visit to North Korea. Reviewers describe someone whose mood swings take over the story. On camera, Rodman yells at an interviewer, drinks too much at practice with teammates, shouts at people at dinner and appears to suffer a breakdown. Kim Jong Un invites Rodman to a ski resort and then cancels the meeting, and Rodman answers with a drinking binge.

Salon read this conduct as a sign of illness or addiction. Variety compared watching the effort to observing a bomb-disposal team.

The game itself

Despite the chaos, the American players beat the North Korean men's national team. That result suggests winning leans heavily on preparation, and on steady professionals who do their jobs while disorder swirls close by. A big personality and real talent are not enough when other people's welfare rests on you.

What athletes and fans can take away

First, fame does not equal readiness. Excellence at the highest level of basketball trains you to compete, not to handle geopolitics.

Second, your reputation travels with everyone you bring along. Both the NBA and the National Basketball Retired Players Association denounced the trip. The NBA also refused to let the filmmakers use archival footage of Rodman, since it wanted no link to the project.

Third, look after the people around you. Narrator Matt Cooper has said that real fear of detention by North Korean officials hung over the making of the film.

Fans should also notice how sharply critics disagreed. Some found the whole affair uproariously funny, and others called it tragic. The Guardian settled on tragicomedy. Viewers will probably get the most from it by approaching with empathy for someone who was plainly struggling.

How the Film was received

Overall, reception was negative. Several reviewers focused on the moment when Rodman sings Happy Birthday to Kim Jong Un during the game, with thousands of spectators watching.

Who made the Film, and where it played

Colin Offland produced and directed this 2015 British documentary, which marked Offland's feature directorial debut. Matthew Baker wrote the script, and Matt Cooper narrates. Slamdance Film Festival audiences saw it first, in January 2015. Showtime put it on television in June 2015, and Manchester Film Festival audiences watched it in March 2016.

The Players who traveled

Rodman first went to North Korea in February 2013. A second trip followed in December 2013, when Rodman went to help train the national team, having built a friendship with Kim Jong Un. The retired NBA veterans who made the journey for the game were Kenny Anderson, Vin Baker, Charles Smith, Cliff Robinson and Doug Christie.

Charles Smith, born in 1965, played in the NBA between 1988 and 1998. At Pittsburgh, Smith earned All-American honors, and the Big East Player of the Year award went to Smith in 1988. Smith also took gold at the 1986 FIBA World Championship and bronze at the 1988 Olympics. After retiring, Smith became an executive director of the retired players association, which makes involvement in this trip all the more striking.

The sporting background

Timing adds context. North Korea last took part in a major event at the 2010 Asian Games. In 2012 FIBA unveiled a sweeping overhaul of international qualification, set to start in 2017, and under the new system North Korea never put a men's national team on court. Seen that way, the exhibition game offers a rare moment of that team in the spotlight.

Sources