Documentary

Facing Ali

Ten Opponents Tell the Story of Muhammad Ali

A stand that cost a championship

The heaviest subject in this documentary is what Ali did in 1967. He declined induction into the United States Army, resting that choice on moral and religious beliefs while the Vietnam War went on. The New York State Athletic Commission took his championship away, and he then had to fight a legal case before he could box again. In 1970 the Supreme Court of the United States ruled in his favor.

Athletes can take a first lesson from this. Standing on principle may damage a career in the short run and still come to define it. Ali would not reverse course and lost his title, and the courts later sided with him.

A name, a faith, and a sense of self

Conviction came naturally to Ali because his identity reached well beyond boxing. He converted to Islam and became Muhammad Ali, leaving behind the name Cassius Marcellus Clay Jr. Briefly, he used Cassius X. Much of his formidable character came from staying loyal to that identity while the public pushed back. Larry Holmes, a former sparring partner, adds another point. In his telling, the champion's edge was built through daily work, and the famous fights were only one part of it.

The Nation of Islam and its time

The film also looks at Ali's tie to the Nation of Islam, whose followers people often called black Muslims. Elijah Muhammad led the group and gave Ali his new name. Archival footage brings in Malcolm X, its most prominent minister, and the broadcaster Howard Cosell.

What the sport takes back

The documentary asks what boxing costs a fighter. Sir Henry Cooper speaks briefly about the way years in the ring wear on Ali's health, and he says the diagnosis is Parkinson's syndrome, not Parkinson's disease. George Chuvalo says he believes the condition came either from boxing or from a predisposition to disease. The film leaves that question open, so viewers should not treat it as settled. Fans can carry away one point: greatness in a combat sport comes with a physical bill.

A legend seen from the other corner

No single narrator guides the viewer here. Instead, ten men who once fought Muhammad Ali tell his story. Each one explains what it meant to stand across the ring from him and how those nights shaped a life and a career. The result shows a legend from the opposite corner, a rare vantage point, and even people who think they know the story will find something new.

The ten witnesses

The ten are Ernie Terrell and Leon Spinks, Earnie Shavers and Ken Norton, Ron Lyle and Larry Holmes, Joe Frazier and George Foreman, along with Sir Henry Cooper and George Chuvalo. Former opponents make unusually credible witnesses. These men lost to Ali, yet they still speak of him with respect, and that sets an example for how competitors can regard one another.

Sonny Liston in archival footage

Sonny Liston appears only in archival footage. He met Ali in two notable fights, in 1964 and 1965, and Liston died in 1970. Neil Leifer's photograph from their second fight, held in Lewiston, Maine, appears on the DVD cover. Many people allege that Liston lost that bout on purpose, and Chuvalo is one of them.

Who made the Film, and how it was received

Pete McCormack directed this 2009 English-language documentary. Derik Murray, Network Entertainment, Lions Gate Entertainment and Spike Sports hold the production credits, and the work was made in association with Muhammad Ali Enterprises. The film qualified for an Academy Award nomination in the documentary feature category but did not receive one. It did win awards from the Vancouver International Film Festival and from the Vancouver Film Critics Circle.

A warning for collectors

Certain copies of the UK DVD release, ARTF0158, carry a chapter fault. The chapters play out of sequence, which makes some sections repeat while one section goes missing altogether.

Sources