Documentary
Freedom Fields
Football and Hope in Post-Gaddafi Libya
The central question
What is a victory worth when the ground keeps shifting? Freedom Fields poses that question through a women's football team, using the squad to examine what Libya's 2011 revolution promised and what came after it. Three friends who met on the soccer field anchor the story. Their devotion to the game becomes a test of whether anyone truly wanted real change. Sport, feminism and a country searching for itself all meet in this documentary, which is the reason to watch it.
What the players actually want
These women ask for very little. Respect, and the chance to play the game they love, is all they seek. Even so, resistance meets that modest wish. The film shows people who struggle to reconcile religion, social habits and the sight of women competing. Opposition swells, particularly online, and some men take offense at women playing in shorts. To those men, shorts are exactly what change looks like, and they reject it.
A team that waited years for a match
For ten years the team had existed, with more than 30 women and girls on its roster, yet not one of them had been permitted to play a match. Then in 2012 the Libyan Football Association allowed the team to compete, in a tournament in Germany against Arab women's teams. The players read that decision as the reward for a long fight and as evidence that the revolution was keeping its word. In this setting, winning means outlasting doubt rather than simply beating an opponent.
Lessons for athletes and fans
Access to the field is a contest in its own right. Before a scoreboard counts for anything, athletes may need to win the right to compete, and that struggle can last years. Fans should keep in mind how many players train and never get a game.
A hard-won opening can also close again. Told that the team will not be allowed to play, the players watch it disband two years later. Victory proves fragile when it rests on a political moment instead of lasting respect.
Commitment matters too. Hope does not die for everyone in the film, and some people remain in the struggle. Naama, Halima and Fadwa each look for their own route to making sense of events and to voicing their love of the game. Loyalty to a sport, fans can conclude, may outlast the institutions around it.
How hope turns to loss
The film is built in three parts, set in 2012, 2014 and 2016. Sorrow dominates the final part, set in 2016, where people conclude that the revolution failed and, if anything, left them worse off. That mood stands in sharp contrast to the opening part, set in 2012, when hope for democracy and gender equality runs high.
The optimism of 2012 had a real basis. Women played key roles in the revolution, from the first protests to smuggling arms and supporting rebels at the front. In the national elections that followed, some women were elected to central roles.
By 2014 confusion and loss have replaced that hope. Libya's civil war escalates as ISIS establishes a presence in the country.
Audre Lorde's 1984 book Sister Outsider, a canonical feminist work, supplies the line that begins the film. That line casts the players' struggle as a battle fought wherever they find themselves.
The filmmaker
Libyan filmmaker Naziha Arebi made Freedom Fields, a 2018 documentary in Arabic and English. Arebi learned of the women's team through an internet message board while working in England, then went back to Libya to meet its players. The film grew out of that personal investigation. Arebi captured the optimism of those early days, and now looks back on it as a kind of naivete that touched creativity, poetry and filmmaking alike.
Two-year jumps separate the film's parts, so Arebi kept filming to fill the gaps. A second documentary, called Revolution, is also planned, and Arebi describes it as even more tragic.
Where the Film has been shown
The Toronto International Film Festival hosted the premiere in September 2018. The British Film Institute then chose the film for a screening in October 2018, and other international festivals followed. The Stockholm International Film Festival nominated it for the Bronze Horse award.
