Documentary

Harvard Beats Yale 29-29

A Football Documentary Worth Your Evening

Why this film deserves your evening

You do not need to follow football to enjoy Kevin Rafferty's 2008 documentary. It takes a single afternoon, a meeting between two undefeated Ivy League teams, and uses it to explore comebacks, memory and the weight one game can carry for the people who played in it. One side falls so far behind that the outcome seems decided. The game then turns completely.

The comeback at the center

Brian Dowling, Yale's quarterback and captain, led a nationally ranked team that arrived as the heavy favorite. Yale sprinted to a 22 to 0 lead. With two minutes left, Yale still led 29 to 13, the kind of score that tells everyone to head for the exits. Then Harvard, coached by John Yovicsin, piled up 16 points in the final 42 seconds and tied the game.

The mindset behind it

Rafferty makes the mental side of the game easy to see. Harvard's players refused to read a lopsided scoreboard as a final verdict. They played each snap as if the clock still counted, because it did. The tie never went into the record books as a Harvard victory. It gave the players something different, a story they have been telling for decades, and the film shows how deeply they treasure it.

What athletes can take away

The first lesson concerns time. The finish took under a minute, and the players still talk about it today. Athletes can conclude that the defining moments of a career may be short and unplanned, so preparation has to cover every second.

Why non-fans respond to it

Critic Bruce Eder noted that people with no interest in football can still enjoy the film. The reason is the human material. Former players reflect on regrets, lessons learned and triumphs that continue to amaze them. Steven Rea of the Philadelphia Inquirer wrote that the film shows how past events keep shaping people's lives. Think of it as a study of how sport stays with a person long after the final whistle.

What the critics said

The documentary drew numerous positive reviews. Michael Sragow of the Baltimore Sun called it Rafferty's greatest work. In the pages of the New York Times, Manohla Dargis described the movie as wildly entertaining. Mark Feeney of the Boston Globe and Tom Keogh of the Seattle Times were enthusiastic as well. Bob Hoover of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette had reservations about the style and the length, yet he praised the stories Rafferty draws out of the aging players.

Who appears on screen

Tommy Lee Jones, a first-team All-Ivy League guard for Harvard, is interviewed in the film, and the film also notes his later success as an Oscar-winning actor. Garry Trudeau, who attended Yale, drew the Doonesbury comic strip, and Dowling inspired its B.D. Yale player Bob Levin remembers dating a Vassar undergraduate named Meryl Streep.

The game and its time

Harvard Stadium hosted the contest on November 23, 1968. Both teams had come in unbeaten, something that had not happened since 1909. The Harvard Crimson ran a headline about the result, and the film took its title from that headline.

The film also sets the game against the backdrop of its era. It includes commentary on the Vietnam War and the sexual revolution, a look at Trudeau's Yale cartoons, and mentions of some players' ties to George W. Bush and Al Gore.

How it was made

Harvard Beats Yale 29-29 is an English-language documentary released in 2008 and directed by Kevin Rafferty. Gravitas Ventures and Kino International distributed it. Rafferty made it essentially as a one-man production. He assembled color kinescope footage of the WHDH telecast, with Don Gillis calling the play-by-play, and combined it with interviews of surviving players.

Sources