Documentary
It Ain't Over
What the Yogi Berra Documentary Says About Winning
Why the film makes its case
Most people know Yogi Berra for his funny sayings. This documentary argues that the jokes have buried one of the most decorated careers in baseball, and it backs that argument with what Berra accomplished both on the field and away from it. Critics have mostly agreed with the film. Anyone who files Berra under punchline first and champion second will find it a useful corrective.
The record and the honors
No player in MLB history has won more World Series titles than Berra, who collected 10 as a player. He also made 18 All-Star selections. The American League Most Valuable Player Award has gone to only six players three times, and Berra belongs to that small group.
He drove in 1,430 runs, hit 358 home runs and posted a .285 career batting average. At only 5 feet, 7 inches tall, he still combined power at the plate with skill behind it as a catcher. No single standout year produced those totals. They came from showing up every season.
Recognition kept coming once his playing days were over. In 1972, Baseball Hall of Fame voters elected him, and the Yankees retired his uniform number 8 in that same year. A plaque in Monument Park followed in 1988, and in 1999 fans voted him onto the MLB All-Century Team.
The catcher from New York
Lawrence Peter Berra, known as Yogi, caught for the New York Yankees. He made his major league debut in 1946 and quickly became a fixture in the lineup that won through the championship years from 1949 to 1962. After the 1963 season he retired as a Yankee, but he came back to play briefly once he joined the New York Mets in 1965.
One of the best known moments of his career came in the fifth game of the 1956 World Series, when Don Larsen threw a perfect game. Berra was the catcher behind the plate.
Berra spent 19 seasons in the major leagues. Catching is the hardest job on the diamond, because a catcher has to manage pitchers, think ahead and absorb physical punishment. His greatest strengths were durability, a calm temperament and a willingness to take on that role.
A modest beginning
Elizabeth Avenue, in a largely Italian neighborhood of St. Louis, is where Berra grew up. Across the street lived Joe Garagiola, a boyhood friend and competitor. Berra left school after the eighth grade to go to work, and in 1943 he signed with the Yankees. When World War II arrived, the United States Navy assigned him as a gunner's mate during the Normandy landings.
Hardly anyone looking at that background would have picked out a future Hall of Famer.
Lessons for athletes and fans
The first lesson is that talent is easy to miss when it does not look the part. Berra was shorter than most players, and his public image leaned toward comedy. Even so, his record places him among the greatest catchers the sport has produced.
The second lesson is the value of staying in the game. After he stopped playing, Berra kept working as a coach and manager, and he returned to the Yankees as a coach in 1976. His career did not end when his playing career did.
The third lesson is about legacy. A museum that carries his name, the Yogi Berra Museum and Learning Center, sits on the Montclair State University campus and opened in 1998. Berra stayed closely involved with it in his later life. Fans can take from this that people can help shape how they are remembered.
About the film
Sean Mullin wrote and directed this American documentary, which was released in 2022. Audiences at the Tribeca Festival saw it first, in June 2022. It reached American theaters on May 12, 2023, and over its opening weekend it earned $88,504 in 99 theaters.
Reviews were strong. Rotten Tomatoes lists 98% positive reviews from 53 critics, with an average rating of 7.9 out of 10. Metacritic reports generally favorable reviews based on 12 critics. The Rotten Tomatoes consensus praises the film for making a persuasive case for his achievements off the baseball diamond.
