Documentary
Jews and Baseball: An American Love Story
Jews and Baseball: An American Love Story, Prejudice, Pride and the National Pastime
What the Film sets Out to show
Jews and Baseball: An American Love Story follows a once-marginalized people as they carved out a place in the American mainstream, using the national pastime as its lens. Generations pass on screen. The earliest players hid their heritage, while modern All Stars carry it openly. Prejudice, assimilation and pride drive the story, and the ballpark becomes a window onto a country that is still working through those questions.
Overcoming stereotypes
Director Peter Miller has said that overcoming stereotypes is the heart of the film. Its message to athletes is that talent can outlast prejudice, and that nobody has to surrender an identity in order to belong. Anyone can hit, pitch and run, the film argues, and anyone can share in the drama of the game.
Fans take away something different. Outsiders have long looked to baseball for acceptance, and the film treats that history as unfinished, with lessons the country continues to wrestle with. Modern players seem to sense this too. Kevin Youkilis suggests that a player may never fully grasp how many people are rooting for them, and that the support goes beyond a single great game.
A fight on two fronts
Jewish ballplayers battled open bigotry and, at the same time, a stereotype that Jews were cerebral and not athletic. The hostility was real. In 1920 Henry Ford wrote that too many Jews were the trouble with American baseball, and some early players changed their names so their background would not be obvious.
The film presents several answers to that pressure. Al Rosen, who had his rookie year in 1950 and won an MVP award in 1953, describes how he handled anti-Semitism on the field. The documentary also notes that some players turned the taunts into fuel. Quiet conviction offers a third answer. Because of Yom Kippur, Sandy Koufax skipped the opener of the 1965 World Series, and Hank Greenberg made the same choice in the middle of a tight pennant race. Both men wanted to win, yet both also stood by who they were.
The players at the center
Key Jewish players from every decade of the sport appear, and Greenberg and Koufax receive special attention. Greenberg won the American League MVP award twice, made five All Star teams and reached the Hall of Fame. For this project Koufax gave a rare filmed interview, and that interview produces the film's most striking sequence.
Other figures add color. Moe Berg spoke seven languages but could not hit. Three times, Lipman Pike topped the National Association in home runs. Barney Pelty, Sam Nahem, Moe Solomon and Shawn Green also turn up in the history, and the more recent stars include Youkilis, Ian Kinsler and Ryan Braun.
The voices and the archive
Bob Feller, Elliott Maddox, Ron Blomberg and Norm Sherry sit for interviews. Yogi Berra, Ron Howard, Larry King and Maury Allen contribute as well. Rare archival footage and photos fill out the era, along with music from Benny Goodman, Yo-Yo Ma and Rush.
How the Film came together
Footage from the 1980 comedy Airplane kicks off the documentary. Peter Miller directed this 2010 English-language production. Ira Berkow, a Pulitzer Prize winner, wrote the script. Academy Award winner Dustin Hoffman narrates, though he first turned the project down.
Release and screenings
Seventh Art Releasing handled distribution, and theatrical runs took place in New York, Los Angeles and other cities. In 2011 the film served as the opening-night feature at the Atlanta Jewish Film Festival, where more than 3,000 people watched at the Fox Theatre. It reached DVD from New Video that same year.
Awards and critical response
At the Breckenridge Film Festival, editor Amy Linton took home the Best Editing Award. In 2011 audiences at the Greater Phoenix Jewish Film Festival and the Seattle Jewish Film Festival each gave it an Audience Choice Award. Kenneth Turan of the Los Angeles Times called it warm and enthusiastic. Variety praised the archival work and the Koufax sequence. Time Out New York described a breezy collection of fun facts and colorful figures, and Newsday found the film stirring and affectionate.
