Documentary
League of Denial
Frontline's Case Against the NFL's Handling of Head Injuries
The central question
If you love football, this film asks what the game owes the people who play it. Frontline made the documentary for PBS, in English, and gave it the name League of Denial, subtitled The NFL's Concussion Crisis. It looks at concussions and chronic traumatic encephalopathy, known as CTE, among players in the National Football League, and at brain injury more broadly. The story follows the scientists who connected football with brain disease, and it shows a league that was slow to accept what they found.
The health Case and its human cost
Long-term health is part of the job, and players are entitled to know the risks. In 2011, players sued the league and argued that nobody had properly told them about the danger of CTE. That claim carries the film's moral argument.
The damage can also be severe. Near the end, the film covers Junior Seau's suicide in 2012 and the lawsuits that thousands of former players later filed against the league. Omalu studied both Seau and Dave Duerson, and each man took his own life while dealing with CTE. Duerson had been an executive with the NFL Players Association. Their cases show why this debate is not abstract, and why the trouble reached far past a single player.
The scientists who kept pushing
The researchers had to win an argument against a powerful institution, and that took stubbornness more than anything. Their biggest stakeholder did not want to hear the finding, yet they pressed it anyway.
Pathologist Bennet Omalu examined the brain of Mike Webster, the Hall of Fame center for the Pittsburgh Steelers, and tied the damage to repeated blows to the head. Ann McKee later led the scientific effort at the research center for traumatic encephalopathy run by Boston University. With colleagues, she studied the brains of numerous former players from the league. Her center gave the story its scientific weight. In this telling, mental toughness means following evidence into uncomfortable territory.
The league's response
Pressure on the NFL was already building. By 2011, Congress was scrutinizing the league, and the NFL was pushed to treat concussions more seriously. The film appeared in 2013, when the lawsuits and the public debate were at their loudest.
Jeff Miller, the NFL's senior vice president for health and safety policy, replied that the league had made a profound commitment to player safety and could point to meaningful, measurable results. The New York Times reviewer disagreed and said the program gives the league little credit for recent rule changes.
What fans and parents take away
Fans carry a share of the responsibility. Reviewers said the film could change how viewers think about football from here on. The New York Times suggested it would open the eyes of parents whose children play the game and who have not followed the issue closely. Frontline had already examined repeated concussions and smaller head blows in high school football, in a 2010 documentary on youth sports.
How the film got made
This was never a film about winning games, and its production showed a similar discipline. ESPN started out as a partner, then withdrew and cited a lack of editorial control. The project went ahead without that backing, which shows how much independence matters when the subject is a league so large.
A 2013 book grew up alongside the film. Its authors, Mark Fainaru-Wada and Steve Fainaru, are reporters for ESPN. Even after the network left the film, it stayed tied to the book deal. It promoted the book and aired excerpts on its program Outside Lines.
Reception and criticism
The documentary won a Peabody Award in 2013, and reviews were largely positive. USA Today called it worth the viewer's time, and Sean Gregory of Time praised the reporting. Some critics pointed out that much of the material had already appeared in print or on screen. The New York Daily News joked that the subtitle might better have blamed a nation in denial.
