Documentary
The Presumption of Justice
Film Analysis
Why watch it
This documentary analyzes the legal aftermath surrounding the tragic death of Toulouse FC supporter Brice Taton following a clash with FK Partizan supporters in Belgrade. It examines claims of institutional mishandling, media pressure, and procedural flaws in the resulting trial of Serbian soccer fans.
About the film
Directed by Boris Malagurski and Ivana Rajovic, the project was produced through Malagurski Cinema. The production runs forty-one minutes and features spoken content in Serbian, French, and English. The theatrical launch occurred in Belgrade on June 29, 2012, followed by screenings in Subotica, Novi Sad, Nis, Backa Palanka, Zrenjanin, Pancevo, Sremski Karlovci, Nova Pazova, and other municipalities. It subsequently had a television debut on Happy TV in April 2013.
The documentary features insights from multiple figures, including Radmila Dragicevic Dicic, who served as head judge of Belgrade's appellate judicial body, and Tomo Zoric, who represented the public prosecution service of Serbia. Legal commentary was also provided by Belgrade University law professor Milan Skulic, attorney Zora Dobricanin-Nikodinovic, and defense counsel Slobodan Batricevic, who represented the family of Stefan Velickovic. The film also includes perspectives from journalist Slobodan Georgijev, former media executive Veran Matic of TV B92, and French academic Loic Tregoures from Universite Lille II.
Lessons for athletes and fans
Supporters and sports organizations must recognize the intense real-world consequences of fan violence. A UEFA Europa League road fixture between FK Partizan and Toulouse FC turned fatal on September 17, 2009, when a violent altercation erupted at Obilicev venac Square. After being attacked, Taton fell from a ledge and died in a medical facility ten days later.
The film explores the severe outcomes for those implicated, highlighting that twelve individuals received convictions. The production argues that public frenzy and premature labeling in news coverage poisoned the environment, creating a setting where nuanced facts were overshadowed by political motives. Athletic events demand restraint from traveling and local supporters alike, as unrest can quickly lead to life-altering tragedy.
Mindset and what it takes to win
In investigative matters, achieving true justice requires an unwavering dedication to factual clarity rather than rushed outcomes. The directors maintain that the legal system rushed the case, resulting in an unjust outcome. A primary focus is Stefan Velickovic, who received a prison term despite an alibi showing he was receiving a traffic ticket on Makedonska street during the altercation blocks away.
The documentary also highlights testimony from Dragan Crepulja, an uncalled witness interviewed during the 2013 television broadcast, who stated he saw Taton fall without anyone beside him on the stairs. Off the screen, the filmmakers encountered intense hostility. In September 2012, they requested an investigation into threats posted on the Parapsihopatologija forum. In July 2013, charges were filed, leading to March 2014 rulings where Rastislav Dinic, Nemanja Poleksic, and Marko Nikolic were found guilty and given suspended sentences with probation. The issue drew critical commentary from writers Milica Jovanovic, Dario Hajric, and Jovana Gligorijevi, sparking responses from Malagurski and historian Cedomir Antic regarding public reactions.
