Documentary
The Short Game
What a Kids' Golf Documentary Reveals About Competing
The big takeaway
Small children can treat a sport as seriously as adult pros do, and The Short Game, a 2013 documentary, shows what that costs and what it gives. Eight golfers, all seven or eight years old, prepare for the U.S. Kids Golf World Championship of 2012. The film is funny and sweet, yet the pressure underneath the cuteness is what stays with you.
What separates the winners
Talent is only one piece of the picture. Allan Kournikova was widely regarded as the best boy in his age group, and he took the boys division. Alexa Pano was considered the top girl in hers. Both results looked like the product of a long, steady build.
Other children arrive by different routes. Yang Kuang first learned the game from golf instruction DVDs found in a store. Amari Avery says the goal is to become like Tiger Woods, a reminder of how early athletes choose a hero. One boy is very intellectual and focused on building his physique, since small golfers need more strength to keep up.
Temper and composure
Feelings matter as much as skill. One strong player has a father who comes across as overbearing, and the child struggles to keep emotions in check after a poor round. Another child is opinionated and sometimes arrogant, and a trainer has to step in when this player shows excitement at an opponent's bad play. A good swing is not enough at any age. Winners also need composure and respect.
Small details, big costs
Preparation covers logistics too. One child lost points because the family misjudged how long a weather delay would last, a simple misunderstanding that cost real ground. Another golfer would have posted the best score in the entire tournament if not for a penalty. Rules, schedules and details shape results as much as talent does.
A warning for parents and fans
The message to adults is plain. Critic John Strege of Golf Digest wrote that youth sports mixed with overzealous parents could have hijacked the movie, but the children are so entertaining that it never does. Michael Whitmer, a critic at the Boston Globe, called the film compelling but tinged with discomfort. Both critics point to the same idea: adults influence how a child experiences competition.
What the kids teach us
The children offer a lesson of their own. Some seem happiest just to be there, and they are thrilled to receive a most improved award. Their joy in the game works as a useful check on a results-first mindset.
Who is on screen
The cast is five boys and three girls, divided evenly between children from the United States and children from other countries. Cameras visit every home, starting about six months before the 2012 championship. Those visits reach Paris, Manila, Johannesburg and Shenzhen, so the story is global from the start.
Sky Sudberry explains golf terms to viewers, which makes the film easy for newcomers. Zamokuhle Nxasana, from Johannesburg, was making a second trip to Pinehurst. Interviews with the golf legends Jack Nicklaus, Gary Player, Chi-Chi Rodriguez and Annika Sorenstam connect the young players to the sport's history.
How critics received it
SXSW Film Festival audiences honored the film in March 2013 with their Audience Award. On Rotten Tomatoes, it holds an average rating of 6.2 and an 83% approval rating. Critics often compared it to Spellbound, the 2002 documentary about the 1999 Scripps National Spelling Bee. Annlee Ellingson of the Los Angeles Times praised its warts-and-all portrait of young golfers. Nicolas Rapold of the New York Times enjoyed its uninhibited cuteness and noted that some subjects are developed more fully than others.
Behind the camera
Josh Greenbaum directed The Short Game, and Justin Timberlake and Jessica Biel served as producers. Samuel Goldwyn Films and Phase 4 Films handled distribution, and viewers can find it on Netflix. The film is in English. Most of the footage comes from the tournament itself, where every child had two crews on hand, one ahead and one behind.
