Documentary
Training Rules
Analysis of the Training Rules Documentary
Why watch it
Institutional prejudice crushed many talented female collegiate athletes, a reality that Training Rules lays bare. Viewers see the mechanics of collegiate athletic exclusion through the lens of Rene Portland leading the Penn State women's basketball program. The narrative traces how targeted players banded together and fought for justice.
About the Film
Co-directors and producers Dee Mosbacher and Fawn Yacker released this American non-fiction project in 2009. The 63-minute English production emerged from Woman Vision, Mosbacher's media enterprise dedicated to advancing equal rights and broad public understanding through instructional cinema. Mosbacher balances work as a film creator, activist, and medical psychiatrist. Diana Nyad lends her voice as narrator, highlighting the secondary title No Drinking, No Drugs, No Lesbians.
Various festivals celebrated the project with honors during 2009. Frameline33 San Francisco International LGBT Film Festival attendees granted it the Best Documentary Audience Award. The Pink Peach Award Jury Award came from the Atlanta Film Festival, and Birmingham Shout Festival participants chose it for their Best Documentary Audience Choice Award. In Colorado Springs, the Pikes Peak Lavender Film Festival selected the movie as Best Documentary. Additionally, judges honored Mosbacher with the initial movie honor bearing Barbara Gittings' name for civil rights work.
Following its initial Philadelphia Film Festival screening, the feature toured to Outfest Los Angeles, Out Film Connecticut, the North Carolina Gay and Lesbian Film Festival, NewFest in New York, the Miami Fort Lauderdale Gay and Lesbian Film Festival, and Toronto's Inside Out Festival. Global audiences also viewed the project abroad during its European debut at Ireland's Gaze Film Festival, the Ljublijana Gay Lesbian Film Festival in Slovenia, and the Paris Feminist Lesbian Film Festival. Several colleges, including Penn State, held campus screenings.
Mindset and what it takes to win
Portland instituted an unbending rule excluding gay athletes the moment she took over Penn State coaching responsibilities in 1980. She compiled 25 winning seasons before departing after 2006, yet severe emotional destruction accompanied those athletic triumphs. Portland pledged immediate dismissal for anyone defying her strict personal regulations.
This hostile climate drove away unprecedented numbers of team members. Almost 46% of athletes playing under Portland transferred or quit despite retaining collegiate eligibility. Once Coquese Washington took the head coaching reins, that figure plummeted to 21%.
Lessons for athletes and fans
Systemic complacency stands out as a primary motif, demonstrating that executive inaction fosters toxic athletic cultures. Penn State enacted formal measures prohibiting sexual orientation discrimination in 1991, yet neither the athletic director nor the university president made Portland follow these rules. Christine Brennan, writing sports columns for USA Today, observed that administrators would have instantly dismissed a coach for targeting ethnic or religious identities similarly.
Players endured profound psychological damage across several decades. Cindy Davies left the roster in silence after Portland threatened public exposure to news outlets and relatives. Portland also forbade team members from interacting with sidelined peers, promising scholarship terminations and athletic blacklisting according to Lisa Faloon. The trajectory shifted entirely when Portland dismissed Jennifer Harris during 2005. Supported by legal action from the National Center for Lesbian Rights, multiple past players provided crucial testimony, producing a 2007 settlement and forcing Portland to resign her position in March 2007.
