Documentary

Up for Grabs

The Documentary About the Ball From Barry Bonds' Record Season

Why this Film matters

Up for Grabs is a comedic documentary from 2004 built on a simple idea: a baseball can be worth enough that two men sue each other over it. The ball in question left Barry Bonds' bat for his record-setting 73rd home run as the 2001 season ended, and two people each said it belonged to them. Everything in the film is true, and the lawsuit that grew from the dispute is Popov v. Hayashi. The filmmakers show less interest in the swing than in the people who raced after the ball once it landed.

Two temperaments, one ball

Putting fans at center stage lets the film comment on what competing really demands. The ball dropped into the right-field bleachers at PacBell Park in San Francisco, and a wild scramble broke out. Fans piled up on the walkway above McCovey Cove, and Patrick Hayashi ended up at the very bottom of the heap. Hayashi stayed in the thick of the crowd, wore a sheepish grin and said very little. In time, Hayashi lifted the ball toward a TV camera so viewers could see who had it.

Alex Popov, who owns a restaurant in Berkeley, chose the opposite route. Popov protested loudly that the ball had been in his hands in mid-air and that somebody had stolen it. Two contrasting personalities were putting forward two contrasting claims to a single prize. Staying calm under pressure, and knowing exactly when to show what you hold, serves a person on a ballfield just as well as it does in a crowd.

Lessons for fans

Fans can learn that proof counts for more than conviction. Josh Keppel, a cameraman for KNTV news, filmed the scene, yet Keppel's footage never showed the ball landing in Popov's glove. That tape became key evidence on the road to the trial in San Francisco Superior Court. Security staff also escorted Hayashi deep into the ballpark so the ball could be authenticated as the genuine record ball. Whatever cameras and authenticators can confirm outweighs loud assertions and fuzzy memories.

Lessons for athletes

A historic moment stops belonging to the athlete almost as soon as it happens. The record ball off Bonds' bat did not stay a keepsake. It turned into evidence, then a legal fight, and finally an auction that sent it to the highest bidder. Anyone whose achievements produce valuable objects should expect strangers to fight over them quickly.

Who appears on screen

Barry Bonds, the San Francisco Giants slugger, anchors the film through his 2001 MLB season. Marty Appel is also among the people featured, alongside Bonds and Hayashi. The film follows the ball from Bonds' bat through the trial and then the auction that came after. Popov, Hayashi, news cameraman Keppel and the court proceedings fill out the cast, and Giants security staff turn up in the chaos right after the catch.

Why the release timing helped

MLB Advanced Media put out the DVD in 2007. That was the MLB season in which Bonds successfully chased Hank Aaron's lifetime home run record, so the release reached baseball fans just as Bonds sat at the center of the sport again.

Production and reception

Michael Wranovics directed and produced the film, which is in English and runs 88 minutes. Laemmle/Zeller Films distributed it. Christopher Guest's mockumentary films inspired the tone, even though the events are real.

Audiences at the 2004 Los Angeles Film Festival gave it their Audience Award for Best Documentary. It also took Best Documentary at both the Gen Art Film Festival and the Phoenix Film Festival. In the Best Underground Movie category, it was a nominee for the Golden Groundhog Award named for William Shatner. Rotten Tomatoes lists a 93% approval rating and an average rating of 7.7 out of 10.

Sources