• Pitcher
  • Cleveland Indians

Allie Reynolds

Allie Reynolds was a pitcher who won 182 games for the Cleveland Indians and New York Yankees and was part of six World Series champions between 1947 and 1953.

Allie Reynolds
Allie ReynoldsPitcher · Cleveland Indians

Fact card

Position
Pitcher
Born
February 10, 1917
Bats
Right
Throws
Right
Height
6 feet 0 inches
Weight
195 pounds
Debut
September 17, 1942
Final game
September 25, 1954
Teams
Cleveland Indians, New York Yankees

Photo: Bowman Gum / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

Early life and path to the majors

Allie Pierce Reynolds was born on February 10, 1917, in Bethany, Oklahoma. He was a member of the Muscogee Nation. He attended Capitol Hill High School in Oklahoma City, where he starred in football as a quarterback and running back. He also excelled in track and field, in the javelin throw and the 100-yard dash.

Oklahoma Agricultural & Mechanical College gave him a scholarship to take part in track, and he also played on the football team. He majored in education and graduated with a lifetime certification to teach public school in Oklahoma.

Baseball coach Henry Iba first noticed Reynolds while he was practicing his javelin throws. Iba asked him to throw batting practice while the team's pitchers recovered from sore arms. Without any warmup pitches, Reynolds struck out the first four batters, and none of them made contact. In his senior year in 1938, he was team captain as an outfielder and pitcher. He led the team to the state conference baseball championship.

The New York Giants of the National Football League drafted him as a halfback. Reynolds preferred baseball and chose not to sign.

Minor leagues

Iba was friends with Hugh Alexander, a scout for the Cleveland Indians. After Iba recommended Reynolds, the Indians signed him as an amateur free agent for a $1,000 signing bonus. He was assigned to the Springfield Indians of the Class-C Middle Atlantic League.

In 1940 he pitched for the Cedar Rapids Raiders of the Class-B Illinois-Indiana-Iowa League. He also played right field for the Raiders when he was not pitching. The Indians wanted to convert him to catcher because of his athleticism, but Reynolds refused to change positions.

He started the 1941 season with the Wilkes-Barre Barons of the Class-A Eastern League. After three appearances he returned to Cedar Rapids. In 1942 he won 18 games and lost 7, with a 1.56 earned run average, 11 shutouts, 21 complete games and 193 strikeouts in 231 innings. That season earned him a promotion to the major leagues.

Cleveland Indians, 1942 to 1946

Reynolds made his major league debut on September 17, 1942. He pitched in two games in relief for the Cleveland Indians that year, throwing 5.0 innings with 2 strikeouts.

In 1943 he began the season as a relief pitcher and made his first start on June 20. Player-manager Lou Boudreau used him as a reliever between starts because of his resiliency. Reynolds won 11 games and lost 12 with a 2.99 earned run average. His 151 strikeouts led the American League, and so did his 6.34 hits allowed per nine innings.

In 1944 he won 11 games and lost 8 with a 3.30 earned run average. In 1945 he won 18 games and lost 12 in 247.1 innings, with a 3.20 earned run average. He was named an All-Star that year. He led the league in walks with 130. In 1946 he won 11 games and lost 15 with a 3.88 earned run average.

Over five years with Cleveland he was used mainly as a starter. He pitched in 139 games, started 100 and finished 27. He completed 41 games, threw 9 shutouts and saved 8 games.

New York Yankees, 1947 to 1954

On October 11, 1946, the Indians traded Reynolds to the New York Yankees for second baseman Joe Gordon. In 1947 he won 19 games and lost 8, with a 3.20 earned run average in 241.2 innings. He had the highest winning percentage in the American League that season, and the Yankees won the World Series.

He won 16 games and lost 7 in 1948 and 17 games and lost 6 in 1949. In 1949 he joined Vic Raschi and Eddie Lopat on a Yankees team that won the first of five consecutive league championships. In 1950 he won 16 games and struck out 160 batters, while pitching with bone chips in his elbow all season.

In 1951 floating chips in his elbow kept him from throwing a pitch in spring training. Dr. George Bennett of Johns Hopkins University recommended against surgery, and Reynolds appeared in his first game one week after the season started. He won 17 games with a 3.05 earned run average and 7 saves. He led the American League with seven shutouts.

On July 12, 1951, he threw a no-hitter against his former team, the Indians, in a 1 to 0 win. Gene Woodling's solo home run was the only run. Reynolds retired the last 17 batters he faced. On September 28, 1951, he threw a second no-hitter, an 8 to 0 win over the Boston Red Sox in which he struck out nine. The win allowed the Yankees to clinch at least a tie for the American League pennant. He was the first American League pitcher to throw two no-hitters in one season.

In 1952 he won 20 games and lost 8. He led the American League in earned run average at 2.06, in strikeouts with 160, and in shutouts with six. He also saved six games. It was the only time he won twenty games.

He still made 15 starts and completed 5 games, and he finished with 13 wins and 13 saves. In July he injured his back when the team bus was on its way to the train station after a game in Philadelphia. In the 1953 World Series, his last, he started the opener and then won the sixth and final game in relief.

In 1954 he won 13 games and lost 4, with 7 saves and a 3.32 earned run average. His final major league game came on September 25, 1954. He retired after that season because of the back injury.

Honors and career line

Reynolds was a six-time All-Star, selected in 1945, 1949, 1950, 1952, 1953 and 1954. He was a six-time World Series champion with the Yankees in 1947, 1949, 1950, 1951, 1952 and 1953. In the postseason he pitched in 15 games with 7 wins, 2 losses and 4 saves. He struck out 62 batters in 77.1 innings. He made six relief appearances in the World Series and earned a win or a save in each one, including the clinching games in 1950, 1952 and 1953.

In 1951 he won the Hickok Belt as the top professional athlete of the year. The New York chapter of the Baseball Writers' Association of America voted him Player of the Year, and he finished third in American League Most Valuable Player voting. In 1952 he was the runner-up for the award.

The Yankees dedicated a plaque in his honor in Monument Park at Yankee Stadium on August 26, 1989. He was inducted into the Oklahoma Sports Hall of Fame in 1986 and the Oklahoma Hall of Fame in 1991. Oklahoma State renamed its baseball stadium after him. In 1993 he received the Jim Thorpe Lifetime Achievement Award. In 1998 the Jim Thorpe Association established the Allie P. Reynolds Award, given each year to an Oklahoma high school senior for scholarship, leadership, civic contributions and character.

Over 13 major league seasons, Reynolds pitched in 434 games and started 309. He won 182 games and lost 107, with a 3.30 earned run average. He threw 2492.1 innings, struck out 1423 batters, completed 137 games, threw 36 shutouts and saved 49 games.

Season by season

Season by season
SeasonTeamGamesWs championPennant
1942Cleveland Indians2falsefalse
1943Cleveland Indians39falsefalse
1944Cleveland Indians41falsefalse
1945Cleveland Indians44falsefalse
1946Cleveland Indians35falsefalse
1947New York Yankees38truetrue
1948New York Yankees41falsefalse
1949New York Yankees37truetrue
1950New York Yankees36truetrue
1951New York Yankees43truetrue
1952New York Yankees41truetrue
1953New York Yankees42truetrue
1954New York Yankees36falsefalse

More about Allie Reynolds

Correct or claim this profile