Bowie Kuhn
Bowie Kuhn was the fifth commissioner of Major League Baseball, serving from 1969 to 1984, and was inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 2008.
BKFact card
Early life and education
Kuhn was born on October 28, 1926, in Takoma Park, Maryland, but he was raised in Washington, D.C. He completed his secondary schooling at Theodore Roosevelt High School. Before enrolling at Princeton, he studied at Franklin and Marshall through the Navy's V-12 program. Kuhn left Princeton in 1947 with honors and a bachelor's degree in economics. He went on to the University of Virginia's law school, where he earned his law degree in 1950. While there he was one of the editors of the law review.
Path to commissioner
After law school, Kuhn joined the New York firm Willkie Farr & Gallagher, which represented the National League. He worked on baseball's legal matters and advised the league in a lawsuit brought by the City of Milwaukee after the Milwaukee Braves moved to Atlanta following the 1965 season. He served as legal counsel for Major League Baseball owners for almost 20 years before he became commissioner. Owners pushed William Eckert out in 1968, and Kuhn emerged as a natural successor. Unlike Eckert, Kuhn knew the inner workings of Major League Baseball well before taking office. His closest rivals were E. Michael Burke, president of the New York Yankees, and Chub Feeney, the San Francisco Giants' head of baseball operations, who instead became National League president. Kuhn was 42 at the time, and he remains the youngest commissioner in history.
Attendance and prime-time baseball
Kuhn's tenure ran from February 4, 1969, to September 30, 1984. Labor strikes, most notably in 1981, and owner dissatisfaction marked those years, and the reserve clause came to an end. Even so, attendance climbed from 23 million in 1968 to 45.5 million in 1983, and television contracts grew over the same period. Kuhn championed prime-time baseball. On October 13, 1971, the World Series staged its first night game, an idea he had pitched to NBC. An estimated 61 million people watched Game 4 on NBC, a figure that daytime broadcasts would not have approached. Weekday Series games stayed at night through the late 1970s and into the 1980s, while most weekend games remained in the afternoon. In 1976, Game 2 was played on a Sunday night to avoid conflict with NBC's NFL coverage, and Kuhn answered criticism by attending the game at Cincinnati's Riverfront Stadium without an overcoat despite the cold. Today every World Series game airs in prime time.
Player discipline
Kuhn suspended many players for drug and gambling involvement. He took a hard line against conduct he judged to be "not in the best interests of baseball." In 1970 he suspended Detroit Tigers pitcher Denny McLain indefinitely over McLain's role in a bookmaking operation. The suspension was later set at three months. Later he suspended McLain for the rest of the season for carrying a gun. Kuhn barred Willie Mays in 1979 and Mickey Mantle in 1983 from the sport over their casino promotion work. Neither was directly involved in gambling. Successor Peter Ueberroth reinstated both in 1985. In 1970 Kuhn called Jim Bouton's book Ball Four "detrimental to baseball" and demanded that Bouton retract it. The book has since been republished several times and is now considered a classic.
Curt Flood and the reserve clause
On October 7, 1969, the St. Louis Cardinals traded Curt Flood, Tim McCarver, Byron Browne, and Joe Hoerner to the Philadelphia Phillies for Dick Allen, Cookie Rojas, and Jerry Johnson. Flood would not report to Philadelphia. He cited the team's poor record, the run-down Connie Mack Stadium, and racist fans. Refusing the trade meant giving up a contract worth US$100,000. In a December 24, 1969 letter, Flood asked Kuhn to declare him a free agent. He wrote that after twelve years in the majors he would no longer accept being bought and sold against his wishes. He said he could play in 1970, asked Kuhn to tell all clubs he was available, and wanted to weigh offers from other teams. Kuhn denied the request, pointing to the reserve clause, the contract language that kept a player tied to a club even after his contract expired. On January 16, 1970, Flood sued Kuhn and Major League Baseball, alleging violations of federal antitrust law. He compared the reserve clause to slavery, a comparison that was controversial even among those who opposed the clause. The case, Flood v. Kuhn (407 U.S. 258), reached the Supreme Court. Flood's lawyer, former Justice Arthur Goldberg, argued that the clause held down wages and tied players to one team for life. Major League Baseball countered that Kuhn had acted under rules meant for the good of the game. The Court ruled 5-3 for Major League Baseball, upholding a 1922 decision in Federal Baseball Club v. National League (259 U.S. 200), and it relied on the principle of standing by earlier decisions.
Feud with Charles O. Finley
Kuhn was known as an owners' commissioner, but he still confronted owners he disliked, including Oakland Athletics owner Charles O. Finley. During the 1973 World Series, Finley made reserve infielder Mike Andrews sign a false affidavit claiming an injury after Andrews made two errors in the 12th inning of Oakland's Game 2 loss to the New York Mets. Andrews' teammates and manager Dick Williams rallied to his defense, and Kuhn forced Finley to reinstate him. In 1976, Finley tried to sell several players to the Boston Red Sox and New York Yankees for $3.5 million. Kuhn blocked the deals, saying they would be bad for the game. The move may have also been payback, since Finley had tried to force an owners' vote to remove Kuhn in 1975. Finley called Kuhn "the village idiot."
Hank Aaron and the 1974 season
At the start of the 1974 season, Atlanta opened on the road in Cincinnati with a three-game series. The Braves wanted Hank Aaron to break Babe Ruth's record of 714 home runs at home, so they planned to sit him for the first three games. Kuhn ruled that Aaron had to play two of the three. Aaron tied Ruth's mark in his first at-bat but hit no more home runs in that series. Kuhn skipped the game where Aaron broke the record, citing a speaking engagement he had already scheduled with a Cleveland Indians booster club.
Ted Turner suspension
In 1977 Kuhn clashed with Atlanta Braves owner Ted Turner. Turner admitted he had made remarks at a cocktail party about acquiring San Francisco Giants star Gary Matthews, at a time when Kuhn had ordered owners not to discuss potential free agents. Kuhn ruled the remarks were not in the "best interest of baseball." He fined Turner, suspended him for one year, and stripped the club of a draft pick. Turner sued, but the trial and appellate courts refused to grant relief, stressing the limited role of judicial review over baseball and the commissioner's office.
Melissa Ludtke's locker room case
In 1977 Melissa Ludtke, a Sports Illustrated reporter, sued Kuhn and the commission for access to the New York Yankees' clubhouse. She had been denied entry during the 1977 World Series and argued that her Fourteenth Amendment rights were violated. She won. The court found a Fourteenth Amendment violation because New York City controlled the clubhouse, and it also found that her fundamental right to pursue a career had been violated based on her sex.
Negro leagues and the Hall of Fame
Kuhn backed honoring Negro league players in the Hall of Fame, but he could not win enough support from the Hall of Fame board of directors. As a compromise he created a committee to select the greatest Negro leagues players, to be honored with a display at the museum in Cooperstown. Satchel Paige was selected as the initial inductee for that display. The separate display drew heavy criticism. Within a few months, the Hall's board reversed course and gave Paige, along with future honorees chosen by the committee, full membership in the Hall. Kuhn wrote in his autobiography that he expected the public outcry to reach the board, and it did. Bill James wrote in The Politics of Glory that Kuhn seemed proud of the episode and suggested he showed personal courage. He also said the public read the affair as saying the Hall was a racist institution, and that Kuhn would have served the Hall better by addressing the problem privately.
Drug policy
Kuhn built a reputation for punishing drug use with heavy fines and suspensions. Darrell Porter, then a Kansas City Royals catcher, later recalled that in the winter of 1979-1980 he became convinced Kuhn knew about his drug use and planned to ban him for life. Porter was named the most valuable player of the 1982 World Series with the Cardinals, and Kuhn was on hand to congratulate him. In 1983, four Kansas City Royals players were found guilty of cocaine use: Willie Wilson, Jerry Martin, Willie Aikens, and Vida Blue. Other established players, including Ferguson Jenkins, Keith Hernandez, Dave Parker, and Dale Berra, admitted drug problems. In 1980, a customs search in Toronto turned up 3.0 grams of cocaine, 2.2 grams of hashish, and 1.75 grams of marijuana on Ferguson Jenkins. Kuhn suspended him indefinitely on September 8. An independent arbiter reinstated Jenkins after two weeks, an unprecedented step, and he returned to play. MLB imposed no further punishment, and he remained active until retiring after the 1983 season.
Leaving office
Kuhn was praised by some and attacked by others for his firm stance against offenders. His hard line on performance-enhancing drugs and the 1981 strike led most owners to turn against him. In 1983 he and his supporters made a last-ditch effort to renew his contract, which failed. The owners chose Peter Ueberroth as the sixth commissioner. Because Ueberroth was then president of the organizing committee for the 1984 Summer Olympics, Kuhn remained commissioner for the 1984 regular season before leaving office.
Life after baseball
After leaving baseball, Kuhn returned to Willkie Farr & Gallagher and became president of the Kent Group, a business, sports, and financial consulting firm. In 1987 he left Willkie to form Myerson & Kuhn with Harvey D. Myerson, a former senior partner at Finley, Kumble, Wagner, Underberg, Manley, Myerson & Casey. He also became an adviser and board member for Domino's Pizza and the Ave Maria Foundation. Kuhn had long lived in Ridgewood, New Jersey. After the firm he formed with Myerson went bankrupt, he sold his home and moved to Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida. His home and other assets had been shielded from the bankruptcy. In May 2001 Kuhn became chairman of the Catholic Advisory Board of the Ave Maria Mutual Funds when the group launched its first mutual fund, the Ave Maria Catholic Values Fund. He was also a member of Legatus, a Catholic organization for presidents and CEOs.
Recognition
Kuhn was named The Sporting News Sportsman of the Year in 1983. He died on March 15, 2007, and was inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 2008.
