Joe McGinnity

JM
Joe McGinnity

Fact card

Position
Pitcher
Born
March 20, 1871
Bats
Right
Throws
Right
Height
5 feet 11 inches
Weight
206 pounds
Debut
April 18, 1899
Final game
October 5, 1908
Teams
Baltimore Orioles, Brooklyn Superbas, New York Giants

Career story

Joe McGinnity was a right-handed pitcher who won 246 games in ten major league seasons from 1899 to 1908 and was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1946.

Early life and the road to the majors

Joseph Jerome McGinnity was born on March 20, 1871, in Cornwall, Illinois. He received little formal schooling. His family moved often, and at the age of eight he went to work in the coal mines. The family later settled in Decatur, Illinois, where he kept mining coal.

In Decatur he began playing baseball with other miners in their free time. He was an outfielder. In 1888 he filled in for his team's pitcher in a game and won it. He kept pitching from then on, and he pitched for semi-professional teams based in Decatur in 1888 and 1889.

Later he organized, managed and pitched for teams in Krebs, in what is now Oklahoma. One of his teams traveled to other towns along the Missouri, Kansas and Texas Railroad to play local clubs.

John McCloskey, manager of the Montgomery Colts of the Class-B Southern League, signed him. He made his professional debut with the Colts in 1893. In 1894 he pitched for the Kansas City Blues of the Class-A Western League.

He later pitched for semi-professional teams in Springfield and Decatur. During this time he developed a sidearm pitch he called Old Sal, a slow curve that became a feature of his later success. While pitching for a semi-professional team, he beat the National League's Baltimore Orioles in an exhibition game. He had already beaten a team from Chatham, Illinois, earlier that day.

Pat Wright signed him to the Peoria Distillers of the Class-B Western Association for 1898. McGinnity won 9 games and lost 4. He allowed only 118 hits and 60 walks while striking out 74 batters in 142 innings. He also pitched a complete 21 inning game, believed to be the second longest professional game to that date.

Baltimore and Brooklyn, 1899 and 1900

A former Brooklyn Grooms player, George Pinkney, saw McGinnity pitch in Peoria. He contacted Brooklyn owner Charles Ebbets and recommended him. McGinnity signed in the spring of 1899. The syndicate that owned Brooklyn also owned the Baltimore Orioles, and manager Ned Hanlon assigned McGinnity to the Orioles after seeing his unusual delivery and slow pitching speed.

In Baltimore he played with John McGraw, who succeeded Hanlon as player-manager, and with Wilbert Robinson, who caught him. McGinnity made his major league debut on April 18, 1899. For the 1899 Baltimore Orioles he won 28 games and lost 16, with a 2.68 earned run average (ERA) in 48 games. His 28 wins led the National League. He ranked second in games, third in ERA and fourth with 366.1 innings.

The National League then voted to contract four teams, including the Orioles, and Hanlon assigned McGinnity to Brooklyn. With the 1900 Brooklyn Superbas he won 28 games and lost 8, with a 2.94 ERA. His 28 wins and 343.0 innings led the league, and Brooklyn won the National League pennant.

He also pitched two complete games in the Chronicle-Telegraph Cup, which the Superbas won against the Pittsburgh Pirates. The team voted to award the trophy to McGinnity.

Back with the Orioles, 1901 and 1902

McGinnity jumped to the American League and signed with the Baltimore Orioles before the 1901 season. He was reunited with McGraw, who was player-manager and part-owner. That year he won 26 games and lost 20, with a 3.56 ERA. His 48 games, 39 complete games and 382.0 innings led the American League.

He began 1902 with the Orioles and won 13 games and lost 10, with a 3.44 ERA. On July 17, 1902, he was released from his Orioles contract. Giants owner Andrew Freedman signed him, and he joined McGraw, now the Giants' player-manager.

New York Giants, 1902 to 1908

With the 1902 New York Giants, McGinnity won 8 games and lost 8, with a 2.06 ERA and 67 strikeouts in 153.0 innings.

In 1903 he won 31 games and lost 20 in 55 games. He started 48 games, pitched 434.0 innings and struck out 171. The 48 starts and 434 innings were MLB records at the time, and the innings mark is still a National League record. On several occasions he started both games of a doubleheader. He did it three times in a single month and won all six games. He pitched over 100 innings in August. He and Christy Mathewson accounted for 73% of the Giants' wins that year, an MLB record for a pitching pair.

In 1904 he won 35 games and lost 8 with a 1.61 ERA. He led the National League in games (51), innings pitched (408), shutouts (9), saves (5) and ERA. On May 21 he recorded his tenth win in his team's 21st game, the fewest team games for a pitcher to reach that mark. Again he won both games of a doubleheader three times within a few weeks. The Giants won the National League pennant.

In 1905 he won 21 games and lost 15 with a 2.87 ERA, and the Giants won the pennant again. They met the Philadelphia Athletics in the World Series. McGinnity started Games Two and Four, winning one and losing one. Mathewson won the other three games. All five games were shutouts, including the one McGinnity lost to Chief Bender. He pitched 17.0 innings in the Series and struck out 6.

In 1906 he won 27 games and lost 12 with a 2.25 ERA, and he led the National League in wins. In 1907 he won 18 and lost 18 in 47 games, with 4 saves and a 3.16 ERA. In 1908 he won 11 and lost 7 in 37 games, with 5 saves and a 2.27 ERA. His final major league game was on October 5, 1908.

Career highlights and honors

McGinnity pitched in 465 games and started 381 of them. He won 246 games and lost 142, with a 2.66 ERA. He completed 314 starts, threw 32 shutouts and recorded 24 saves. Over 3441.1 innings he struck out 1068 batters.

He had seven 20-win seasons and two 30-win seasons. He led MLB in wins five times, in 1899, 1900, 1903, 1904 and 1906, and led in ERA once, in 1904. His teams won National League pennants in 1900 and 1904, and the Giants won the 1905 World Series.

He was nicknamed Iron Man because he worked in an iron foundry during the offseasons. The name came to stand for his durability, as he regularly pitched both games of doubleheaders. He continued to pitch in the minor leagues and retired from baseball for good at the age of 54. Including his minor league wins, he won close to 500 games as a professional.

At the plate he collected 251 hits and 26 stolen bases. He was inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1946.

Facts

  • Born: March 20, 1871, in Cornwall, Illinois
  • Debut: April 18, 1899
  • Final game: October 5, 1908
  • 1899 record: 28 wins, 16 losses, ERA 2.68 for the Baltimore Orioles
  • 1900 record: 28 wins, 8 losses for the Brooklyn Superbas
  • 1901 record: 26 wins, 20 losses for the Baltimore Orioles
  • 1903 innings: 434.0 innings and 48 starts for the New York Giants
  • 1904 record: 35 wins, 8 losses, ERA 1.61
  • 1905 record: 21 wins, 15 losses, ERA 2.87
  • 1906 record: 27 wins, 12 losses, ERA 2.25
  • 1907 record: 18 wins, 18 losses, ERA 3.16
  • 1908 record: 11 wins, 7 losses, ERA 2.27
  • Career pitching: 246 wins, 142 losses, 2.66 ERA, 1068 strikeouts
  • World Series: 1905 New York Giants
  • Pennants: 1900 Brooklyn Superbas and 1904 New York Giants
  • Honor: National Baseball Hall of Fame, inducted 1946
  • Postseason pitching: 2 games, 17.0 innings, 6 strikeouts in 1905
  • Wins leader: Led MLB in wins five times

Batting, season by season

yearteamGABRH2B3BRBISBBBSOAVG
1899Baltimore Orioles501452128··104519.193
1900Brooklyn Superbas46145182841164117.193
1901Baltimore Orioles4814812312163420.209
1902Baltimore Orioles27871025248225.287
1902New York Giants256638··3··6.121
1903New York Giants5516512341·114421.206
1904New York Giants5114210254271214.176
1905New York Giants46120112861114715.233
1906New York Giants45115315118·318.130
1907New York Giants47103618··33515.175
1908New York Giants37613111·7118.180

Statistics: SABR Lahman Baseball Database (CC BY-SA 3.0).

Pitching, season by season

yearteamWLGGSCGSHOSVIPHERHRBBSOERA
1899Baltimore Orioles281648413842366.1358109393742.68
1900Brooklyn Superbas2884437321·343.03501125113932.94
1901Baltimore Orioles262048433911382.0412151796753.56
1902Baltimore Orioles1310252319··198.221976346393.44
1902New York Giants881916161·153.012235132672.06
1903New York Giants312055484432434.039111741091712.43
1904New York Giants35851443895408.0307738861441.61
1905New York Giants211546382623320.12891026711252.87
1906New York Giants271245373232339.2316851711052.25
1907New York Giants181847342334310.13201096581203.16
1908New York Giants1173720755186.019247837552.27

Statistics: SABR Lahman Baseball Database (CC BY-SA 3.0).

Sources and credits

Correct or claim this profile