- Pitcher
- Cleveland Indians
Mike Garcia
Mike Garcia was a right-handed pitcher who spent most of his 1948 to 1961 career with the Cleveland Indians and won 142 games, including a 22-win season in 1952.

Fact card
- Position
- Pitcher
- Born
- November 17, 1923
- Bats
- Right
- Throws
- Right
- Height
- 6 feet 1 inch
- Weight
- 195 pounds
- Debut
- October 3, 1948
- Final game
- September 2, 1961
- Teams
- Cleveland Indians, Chicago White Sox, Washington Senators
Early life and the road to the majors
Edward Miguel Garcia, known as Mike, was born on November 17, 1923, in San Gabriel, California. He was of Indigenous Gabrieleño and Mexican heritage. He grew up on a ranch in Orosi, California. He played four years of high school baseball, the first three at Orosi High School and the last at Visalia High School.
Garcia was pitching in semipro baseball when Cleveland Indians scout Willis Butler noticed him in Tulare, California. In 1942, Butler signed him as an amateur free agent to the Appleton Papermakers of the Wisconsin State League, a Class D farm team. Garcia earned 10 wins and 10 losses with Appleton. He then spent three years as a signalman in the United States Army during World War II, serving in Europe with the Signal Corps.
After his discharge, Garcia returned to the Cleveland organization and pitched for the Class C Bakersfield Indians of the California League. His earned run average and strikeouts led the league, and he earned 22 wins. In 1947 he joined the Indians during spring training. Coach Bill McKechnie assigned him to the Class A Wilkes-Barre Barons of the Eastern League, where he finished with 17 wins and a 3.24 ERA. In 1948 he pitched for the Double-A Oklahoma City Indians of the Texas League and earned 19 wins.
Cleveland and the Big Four, 1948 to 1951
Garcia debuted with the Cleveland Indians on October 3, 1948, just before the 1948 World Series. He allowed three hits and no runs in two innings and struck out one batter. The Indians won the World Series in six games. Garcia did not make a World Series appearance.
Teammate Joe Gordon gave him the nickname Big Bear for his large frame. The press also called him Mexican Mike. Early on, Garcia roomed with Bobby Ávila, who had just signed with the club and did not speak English. Garcia served as a translator for Ávila well beyond their first season together.
In 1949, Garcia appeared in 41 games and started 20 of them, working as both a starter and a reliever. He finished with 14 wins and 5 losses, a league-leading 2.36 ERA, 94 strikeouts and five shutouts. That spring, pitching coach Mel Harder taught him a curveball. Harder said Garcia already had a terrific fastball and became a good pitcher by learning the curveball and working on his control. In 1950, Garcia went 11 and 11 with 184.0 innings pitched.
By 1951, the press had given the name Big Four to the pitching group of Garcia, Bob Feller, Bob Lemon and Early Wynn. That season Garcia won 20 games and lost 13 over 254.0 innings. His six saves placed him fifth in the American League. On June 4, he threw a 10-hit complete game in an 8 to 2 win that helped the Indians beat New York Yankees pitcher Ed Lopat for the first time in two years. Lopat had started the season 8 and 0. On August 7 against the St. Louis Browns, Garcia reached a career-high 15 wins in a 5 to 1 victory. He also hit the second home run of his career in that game.
All-Star seasons, 1952 to 1954
In 1952, Garcia made the first of three consecutive All-Star teams. He began September with three consecutive shutouts during an eight-game Indians win streak. He finished 22 and 11 with 143 strikeouts, four saves and an American League best six shutouts. His 2.37 ERA was second in the league, as were his 46 games and 292.1 innings pitched. He tied Lemon for the league lead with 36 starts. Garcia finished ninth in the MVP voting.
In 1953, Garcia and Lemon were named pitchers on the American League All-Star squad. Garcia went 18 and 9 with 134 strikeouts and a 3.25 ERA over 271.2 innings. He pitched a career-high 29 complete games.
On May 16, 1954, Garcia pitched a one-hitter against the Philadelphia Athletics in a 6 to 0 Indians win. He called it the finest game of his career. American League manager Casey Stengel added him to the All-Star roster for his third and final selection. A broken blood vessel in his throwing hand cost him several games, but he still made 45 appearances. He finished 19 and 8 with 129 strikeouts and five saves over 258.2 innings. He led the American League in both ERA, at 2.64, and shutouts, with five.
The 1954 Indians finished 111 and 43, a record for a 154-game season, and posted a team ERA of 2.78. Cleveland met the New York Giants in the World Series. Garcia started game three, and the Giants won 6 to 2. He pitched two games in the postseason, covering 5.0 innings with four strikeouts.
Final seasons: Cleveland, Chicago and Washington
In 1955, Garcia went 11 and 13 with a 4.02 ERA. The Indians finished second at 93 and 61, three games behind the Yankees. In 1956 he went 11 and 12 with a 3.78 ERA, and his four shutouts tied for second in the league behind fellow Indian Herb Score. In 1957 he finished 12 and 8 with a 3.75 ERA over 211.1 innings.
In March 1958, Garcia slipped on a wet pitcher's mound during a spring training game and injured his back. He made his first regular season appearance on April 27 and had surgery in June for a herniated disc. He finished with one win and no losses in six appearances. After the season he became a free agent but returned to the Indians, saying his home and his dry cleaning business were in Cleveland. In March 1959, a line drive from Billy Consolo hit him in the knee. He made his first start of that season on May 3, allowing four hits and no earned runs in a complete game. He finished 3 and 6 with a 4.00 ERA over 72.0 innings in his twelfth and final season with the Indians.
Garcia signed with the Chicago White Sox for 1960, reuniting with manager Al López and former Indians owner Bill Veeck. He pitched 15 games and 17.2 innings with two saves and a 4.58 ERA. In July 1961, the expansion Washington Senators signed the 37-year-old Garcia. He pitched 16 games and 19.0 innings with 14 strikeouts and a 4.74 ERA. His final major league game came on September 2, 1961.
Career highlights
Garcia played 14 major league seasons, 12 of them with Cleveland. From 1949 to 1954, he and Lemon, Wynn and Feller formed the Indians Big Four pitching staff. In those six seasons, Garcia compiled 104 wins against 57 losses. He had two 20-win seasons and led the American League in ERA and shutouts twice each.
His career line shows 142 wins and 97 losses in 428 games, with 281 starts, 111 complete games, 27 shutouts and 23 saves. He pitched 2174.2 innings, struck out 1117 batters and finished with a 3.27 ERA. At the plate he collected 127 hits and two home runs. He is a member of the Cleveland Indians Hall of Fame and has been included on a list of the 100 Greatest Indians. Garcia also raced midget cars during and after his baseball career.
Season by season
| Season | Team | Games | Ws champion | Pennant |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1948 | Cleveland Indians | 1 | true | true |
| 1949 | Cleveland Indians | 41 | false | false |
| 1950 | Cleveland Indians | 33 | false | false |
| 1951 | Cleveland Indians | 47 | false | false |
| 1952 | Cleveland Indians | 46 | false | false |
| 1953 | Cleveland Indians | 38 | false | false |
| 1954 | Cleveland Indians | 45 | false | true |
| 1955 | Cleveland Indians | 38 | false | false |
| 1956 | Cleveland Indians | 35 | false | false |
| 1957 | Cleveland Indians | 38 | false | false |
| 1958 | Cleveland Indians | 6 | false | false |
| 1959 | Cleveland Indians | 29 | false | false |
| 1960 | Chicago White Sox | 15 | false | false |
| 1961 | Washington Senators | 16 | false | false |
