Career story
Early life and college
Mitch Tinsley was born on September 15, 1999, and is from Lee's Summit, Missouri. At Lee's Summit High School, he caught 19 passes for 350 yards and six touchdowns as a senior. He also participated in basketball and track and field.
Tinsley played two seasons at Hutchinson Community College in Kansas and two at Western Kentucky, where he earned second-team All-Conference USA honors in 2021. He finished his college career at Penn State and majored in media studies.
In his lone Penn State season in 2022, he caught 51 passes for 577 yards and five touchdowns in 13 games, including 10 starts. Across his final three college seasons at the Division I level, he played 39 games with 33 starts and totaled 181 catches for 2356 yards and 23 touchdowns.
Washington
The Washington Commanders signed Tinsley as a college free agent on 5-12-23. He played in 2 games as a rookie in 2023 and did not record any stats. He made his NFL debut on Sept. 17 at Denver, playing three offensive snaps, and played seven special teams snaps on Jan. 7 against Dallas. He was inactive for 15 games.
Washington waived him on 8-27-24 and signed him to its practice squad on 8-28-24. He spent the 2024 season on the practice squad and did not play. He did not earn an accrued year of experience toward NFL free agency that season, and his practice squad contract expired on 2-3-25.
First season in Cincinnati
Tinsley signed with the Cincinnati Bengals as a free agent on 2-4-25 and earned an active roster spot after training camp and the preseason. He caught six passes for 88 yards and two touchdowns in the 2025 preseason, with both scoring catches coming at Washington.
In the 2025 regular season, he played 17 games with 4 starts and caught 8 passes for 116 yards and 2 touchdowns. He averaged 14.5 yards per catch, with a long of 27 yards, 6 first downs, a 75 percent first-down rate and 1 reception of at least 20 yards. He returned 1 punt for 10 yards and made 2 fair catches.
His first NFL reception was a one-handed, 13-yard touchdown catch against Jacksonville on Sept. 14 that tied the game in the third quarter. Against Chicago on Nov. 2, his 27-yard catch from Joe Flacco set up a Bengals touchdown. Tinsley caught a 17-yard touchdown in his first start against New England on Nov. 23, then made two catches for 22 yards at Baltimore on Nov. 27.
2026 and career totals
Tinsley signed a contract extension with Cincinnati on 1-5-26. Through 4 games of the 2026 season, he has 5 receptions for 60 yards, averaging 12 yards per catch with a long of 29. Those catches include 4 first downs, an 80 percent first-down rate and 1 gain of at least 20 yards. He has also made 1 solo tackle.
Through that point in 2026, Tinsley has played in 23 NFL games and caught 13 passes for 176 yards and 2 touchdowns. He has a 13.5-yard receiving average, a long of 29, 10 receiving first downs, a 76.9 percent first-down rate and 2 receptions of at least 20 yards. The Bengals wide receiver wears number 82 and is listed at 6-1 and 205 pounds.

