Alec Connell
Canadian goaltender who played for four NHL teams in the 1920s and 1930s, set major shutout and goals-against records, and was inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame.
ACFact card
Amateur career
Nicknamed The Ottawa Fireman, Connell was stationed in Kingston, Ontario, while serving in the military during the First World War. In 1917 the junior Kingston Frontenacs recruited him. He reportedly could not skate at the time, so he spent two seasons as the team's backup goaltender. Connell also excelled at other sports. He was a catcher in the Interprovincial League, played lacrosse for the Ottawa club that won the Canadian championship in the 1920s, and played hockey for St. Brigid's in the Ottawa City Hockey League. By then a skilled goaltender, he spent five seasons in the Ottawa City Hockey League, mostly with St. Brigid's, after King Clancy, a future Senators player and Hall of Famer, recruited him.
Ottawa Senators
Connell joined the Ottawa Senators for the 1924-25 season after the team sent aging star goaltender Clint Benedict to the expansion Maroons. He made an immediate impact. He led the league with seven shutouts in 30 games, a total that broke the NHL record, and guided Ottawa to a third-place finish. That season he took part in the first 0-0 tie in NHL history, on December 14 against the Hamilton Tigers. Jake Forbes was the opposing goalie. In 1926 he more than doubled the NHL record for shutouts, reaching 15, and set a new league low goals-against average of 1.12. In 1927 he became the first goaltender to record a 30-win season. In the playoffs he allowed only four goals in six games as Ottawa beat the Boston Bruins in the final, the eleventh and last Stanley Cup title for the Senators. In 1927-28 he set an NHL record for the longest shutout streak, 461:29, which stood unbroken as of 2022. It came from seven consecutive shutouts plus another 41 minutes in an eighth game, played between January 31 and February 22, 1928. That season's Stanley Cup Final pitted the Montreal Maroons against the New York Rangers, and Connell attended as a spectator. When Rangers goaltender Lorne Chabot was injured, coach Lester Patrick asked for Connell to replace him. The Montreal coach refused, so Patrick played in goal himself, an event that became one of the most famous incidents in league history.
Detroit, New York and return to Ottawa
Ottawa struggled as a small market team hit hard by the Great Depression. While the Senators sat out the 1932 season, Connell played on loan for the Detroit Falcons. That season he clashed with a goal judge reputed to be a hitman for the mob of bootlegger Bill Dwyer, after a disputed call in a game against the New York Americans, which Dwyer owned. He needed police protection to leave the arena after the game. He returned to Ottawa for 1932-33 and was named team captain. An injury in a December 6, 1932 game against the Chicago Black Hawks limited him to sporadic play, with Bill Beveridge filling in. After he was pulled from a December 26 game against the Rangers following four goals, he announced his retirement. He reportedly told coach Cy Denneny, "Your move was the height of stupidity." He fully recovered by January 1934. The Montreal Maroons wanted him on a loan basis only, but the financially strapped Senators insisted on a cash deal and rejected the offer. Injuries kept him out for most of the 1934 season, and Beveridge replaced him in net. On March 15, 1934, New York Americans goaltender Roy Worters was hurt in the first period. Ottawa loaned Connell for the rest of the game. He led New York to a 3-2 win and was named the star of the game. That game was the last home game in the Senators' forty-year history, because the franchise moved to St. Louis the following year.
Montreal Maroons
The Senators traded Connell's rights for Glenn Brydson, and he returned from semi-retirement to play for the Maroons in 1935. Coach Tommy Gorman, who had won the Stanley Cup with Chicago the previous season, had urged him to come back. At 33 he returned to his old form. He led the NHL in shutouts for the fourth time and finished second to Chicago's Lorne Chabot in Vezina Trophy voting for the league's leading goaltender. That season he allowed the first penalty shot goal in league history, scored by Ralph Bowman of St. Louis on November 13. The penalty shot had been newly instituted that season. In the 1935 playoffs he went undefeated and helped the Maroons win the Stanley Cup, allowing only four goals in the Cup Final. Gorman called his play the "greatest goalkeeping performance in the history of hockey." Throughout his playing career, Connell held offseason administrative positions with the Ottawa Fire Department. He could not get a leave of absence from his job there as secretary, so he retired again. He returned for the 1936-37 season to platoon with Beveridge. His form had faded, and he played his last game on January 16, 1937.
Records and legacy
When he retired, Connell ranked second in NHL career shutouts. Nearly ninety years later he still ranks sixth, with 81. He is the only goaltender in league history to record 15 or more shutouts in two separate seasons. His career goals-against average of 1.91 is the lowest in NHL history, a mark he has held for over ninety years. He is also the career leader in playoff goals-against average among goaltenders who played more than twenty games. He is widely regarded as one of the greatest goaltenders of all time. In 1927 he was among the first goaltenders to move from the cricket-style pads of early hockey to wider leather-and-kapok pads, pioneered by Hamilton harnessmaker Pop Kenesky. He was inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame in 1958, but he died on May 10, 1958, after a lengthy illness, before his formal induction. The Society for International Hockey Research later ruled that he would have won a retroactive Conn Smythe Trophy in 1927 had the award existed then. Charles Coleman, in Trail of the Stanley Cup, believed he would have won the Vezina Trophy in 1926 by the same reasoning.
