Coach

Hal Chase

Prince Hal, Star First Baseman and Short-Time Manager

Who he was

Hal Chase, known as Prince Hal, played first base in Major League Baseball and also managed for a short time. Plenty of observers considered Chase the best fielding first baseman the game ever produced. Babe Ruth and Walter Johnson each declared that they had never watched a better player at the position, and sportswriters of the day lauded the glovework as outstanding. By some accounts, the club that later turned into the New York Yankees found its earliest genuine star in Chase. Even so, people still argue about what Chase left behind.

How the career unfolded

Santa Clara College is where Chase's baseball life started. In 1904 the Los Angeles Angels of the Pacific Coast League, a Class-A circuit, handed Chase a first professional contract. New York took Chase from Los Angeles in that October's Rule 5 draft, and the Highlanders added Chase to their roster in 1905.

Chase remained with the Highlanders from 1905 to 1913, so New York was the first stop. From 1913 to 1914 the Chicago White Sox had Chase on the payroll, followed by the Buffalo Blues from 1914 to 1915. The Cincinnati Reds came next, from 1916 to 1918, and the New York Giants were home for the final season, 1919.

Salary fights and winter ball

California's winter leagues appealed to Chase, who played in them during nearly every offseason. In 1907 Chase held out, threatening to jump to an outlaw California League unless the Highlanders lifted the salary to $4,000. Chase eventually agreed to report that April but still demanded the right to play in California over the winter. The National Commission responded with a ruling that suspension awaited any player who stayed in that league. Chase kept playing anyway, under the name Hal Schultz. California clubs paid little attention to the National Agreement, and in 1908 Chase went back to a major league team that reinstated the first baseman.

Later that same season, the Highlanders dismissed Clark Griffith. Chase would not play for Kid Elberfeld, the new manager, and headed back to California in September. Chase suspected team management of planting a damaging story with a local newspaper. Chase nonetheless finished the season, paid a fine, and won reinstatement for 1909.

In charge of the Highlanders

Late in 1910, Chase took over as player-manager, replacing George Stallings. Stallings charged that Chase had thrown games on purpose to clear the way to that position, and warned the club that Stallings would resign unless Chase departed. A September meeting ended with Yankees management backing Chase and letting the manager go. Chase led the team through 1911 and left the post once that season was over.

A rough 1913

Chase held a three-year contract with New York, yet 1913 went poorly. The batting average dropped, and injuries cut into Chase's playing time. Frank Chance voiced a worry that Chase was laying down. Chance afterward explained that the true doubt concerned whether Chase could summon the energy to climb out of the slump. On June 1, 1913, New York sent Chase to Chicago and received Babe Borton and Rollie Zeider in exchange.

The Federal League and a landmark Court case

Early in 1914, Chase walked away from Chicago and signed with Buffalo of the Federal League. The Blues belonged to a rival circuit that hoped to challenge the American and National Leagues. Charles Comiskey, who owned the White Sox, moved at once to stop the switch and filed for a court order in New York State Supreme Court. Comiskey argued that the reserve clause bound Chase to Chicago forever. Chase hired a lawyer and fought back, and the case was brought as the American League Baseball Club of Chicago against Chase.

In July 1914, Justice Herbert Bissell ruled for Chase. Bissell found that organized baseball amounted to a complete monopoly, one that violated common law rights tied to labor contracts. The court also observed that the arrangement had no mutuality at all. Chicago could release Chase at any moment, while Chase had no way to leave. Legal attacks on the reserve clause system seldom succeeded this early, and the decision stood largely unchallenged until Curt Flood filed suit in 1970.

Flood had a union behind the case, but Chase had none, and the public paid little attention. Baseball's power structure hit back instead. Ban Johnson, who presided over the American League, joined Comiskey in effectively blacklisting Chase from the American League. Both men wielded real influence. That hostility left Chase with few allies among owners and league officials when corruption allegations surfaced later.

Return to the National League

Chase played very well across two Federal League seasons and led the circuit in home runs in 1915. After that season the league stopped operating, and Chase signed with the Cincinnati Reds. The blacklist that grew out of the lawsuit shut Chase out of every American League club. In 1916, Chase's batting average was the best in the National League.

The gambling charges

Rumors of gambling and game-fixing trailed Chase, and they grew louder after the 1914 victory over Comiskey. In an August 1918 interview, Ban Johnson confirmed that the American League had barred Chase. Johnson blamed the ban on how Chase had dealt with Comiskey, not on gambling. Christy Mathewson, who managed Cincinnati, also made accusations in 1918. Mathewson claimed that Chase played with indifference, bet on games and threw them. Mathewson was suspended indefinitely. John Heydler, the National League president, looked into the charges in 1919 and cleared Chase. An indictment tied to the Black Sox scandal followed later, and Chase was acquitted. No court ever convicted Chase of any crime. Although organized baseball effectively closed its doors anyway, Commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis did not issue a formal ban. Historians keep debating one question. Was the damaged reputation earned through proven corruption, or did the baseball establishment that Chase had challenged simply punish a rebel?

His booklet and his place in history

Chase wrote a booklet in 1917 titled How to Play First Base. The American Sports Publishing Company of New York released it as part of the Spalding Athletic Library. Active players rarely wrote guides for that series themselves. Chase shared opinions on first-base technique, fielding strategy and positioning, and the booklet included diagrams and photographs that illustrated proper form. Scholars regard it as culturally significant. Copies sit in the Library of Congress and other large research libraries, and the work remains in the public domain.

The historians Lawrence Ritter and Donald Honig placed Chase in their 1981 book profiling baseball's 100 greatest players of all time. Chase appeared in a last major league game in 1919 and died in 1947.

Sources