Ban Johnson
Ban Johnson was an American baseball executive who founded the American League and served as its first president until a dispute with commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis forced him out.
BJFact card
Early career
Johnson was born in Norwalk, Ohio. He studied law at Marietta College but never earned a degree. He later became a sports editor at a Cincinnati newspaper, where he became friends with Charles Comiskey, then manager of the Cincinnati Reds.
Western League
In 1894, at a reorganization meeting, Johnson was elected president of the Western League, a struggling minor league. Comiskey and Reds owner John T. Brush encouraged the move. Johnson had criticized the National League for a rowdy atmosphere that was keeping families and women away from games. He set out to make the sport welcoming to both. He backed his umpires firmly and expected players and managers to respect them. He fined or suspended players who swore on the field. Under his leadership the Western League became the strongest minor league and was regarded as the best managed league in baseball.
Founding the American League
Johnson wanted a second major league. With Comiskey's help, he pursued an ambitious expansion plan. After the 1899 season, the National League dropped teams in Baltimore, Cleveland, Louisville and Washington, D.C. Johnson moved the Grand Rapids franchise to Cleveland, and Comiskey relocated his Saint Paul team to Chicago. The National League accepted the Chicago move as a way to block any revival of the American Association. For the 1900 season, the Western League was renamed the American League, though it remained a minor league. The 1900 season was a clear success, and Johnson received a 10-year contract extension. That October he withdrew the American League from the National Agreement. On January 28, 1901, he declared the American League a major league and placed teams in Baltimore, Boston, Philadelphia and Washington. Johnson had promised Buffalo a place in the new league, then dropped the franchise and moved it to Boston. It later came out that he had been negotiating secretly with Boston figures for months and had money invested in the Boston club. He also held a large stake in the Washington franchise until 1903.
Building a major league
In 1901 the National League capped player salaries at $2,400 per year. Johnson and Comiskey answered by signing National League players with much higher pay. More than 100 players moved to the American League. After two years of competition, in which the American League outdrew the National League both seasons, the National League agreed to peace. Under a new National Agreement, the American League was recognized as the second major league. A three-man National Commission was formed, made up of both league presidents and Reds owner Garry Herrmann. Herrmann was the nominal president of the commission, but Johnson soon dominated it. Johnson did not tolerate criticism and made it difficult for owners he disliked to join the league. When Harry Frazee bought the Boston Red Sox in 1917, Johnson tried almost immediately to force him out, because Johnson had not chosen him. At one point Johnson held ownership interests in both the Cleveland and Washington clubs.
Decline
The league split into two factions. The Red Sox, White Sox and New York Yankees sided against Johnson, while the other five clubs, the Loyal Five, supported him. Comiskey became a bitter enemy. Johnson's authority weakened further when the Red Sox traded Carl Mays to the Yankees despite Johnson's order to suspend him. The Yankees won a court injunction allowing Mays to play. Johnson's investment in the Cleveland club made it hard for him to appear impartial. After the 1920 season, the Black Sox Scandal broke. Some American League clubs threatened to leave for a new league. Frank Navin, a Johnson loyalist, instead persuaded the other clubs to set up a National Commission of non-baseball men. Federal District Court Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis was named chairman. Landis agreed to serve only as sole Commissioner of Baseball, with unlimited power over the game, and the owners accepted his terms. Johnson and Landis clashed before the 1924 World Series. Landis barred two New York Giants from the Series over an attempt to bribe Philadelphia Phillies players. Johnson demanded the Series be canceled and publicly criticized Landis, who threatened to resign. The American League owners warned Johnson that he would be removed if he stepped out of line again. He stayed in office for two years, receiving a contract extension to 1935 and a raise to $40,000 from $25,000. In 1926 Johnson criticized Landis for granting Ty Cobb and Tris Speaker amnesty after evidence surfaced that they had fixed a 1919 game. Landis told the American League to choose between them. The owners planned to remove Johnson at their January 1927 meeting, but because Johnson was in ill health, they placed him on an indefinite sabbatical instead. He tried to return in the spring and act as if nothing had changed, but he was forced to resign at the end of the season. Navin served as acting president until the owners chose Indians general manager Ernest Barnard as president.
Legacy
Johnson died on March 28, 1931, in St. Louis, Missouri, within hours of his successor, Ernest Barnard. He was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1937 as one of its charter members. The athletic fieldhouse at Marietta College is named for him. He was buried at Riverside Cemetery in Spencer, Indiana. The Jayhawk Collegiate League's Liberal Bee Jays are named in his honor. Will Harridge, who succeeded to the American League presidency in 1931, said of Johnson: "He was the most brilliant man the game has ever known. He was more responsible for making baseball the national game than anyone in the history of the sport"
