Coach

Jimmy McAleer

Outfielder, Manager and Builder of the American League

Overview

Jimmy McAleer played center field, later managed in the majors, and eventually owned stock in a big league club. McAleer also helped the American League grow. Cleveland, St. Louis and Washington each had McAleer as their manager. McAleer died in 1931.

Early life and minor leagues

McAleer grew up in Youngstown, Ohio, and finished schooling at Rayen High School. Speed drew early attention to McAleer. A start with the hometown club led to stops in Charleston, South Carolina, and Memphis, Tennessee. McAleer's last minor league stop came in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and by then the center fielder had built a reputation. The theater appealed to McAleer too. McAleer owned a share of the DeHaven Comedy Company, a traveling theatrical troupe assembled in Youngstown, and stayed friends for many years with George M., a Broadway composer and performer.

The cleveland Spiders

Once in the majors, McAleer earned a name for graceful play in the outfield for the Spiders. Manager Patsy Tebeau ran a club with a rough, combative style, and McAleer's temper fit that atmosphere. In one game against Cincinnati, Arlie Latham tripped McAleer on the bases, and McAleer went after Latham with a bat. After a separate incident, a judge in Louisville fined McAleer and several teammates. The club's reputation fell so low that other National League teams floated the idea of a boycott.

Still, McAleer produced. One newspaper described McAleer as an outstanding outfielder with excellent speed, and stolen bases came regularly. Some accounts credit McAleer as the first center fielder to turn away from a fly ball and run to the spot where it would come down. Hitting was a lesser strength by comparison. The Spiders won the Temple Cup series, a postseason matchup between the National League's top two finishers, over Baltimore, and McAleer played in it despite a serious injury from running into a fence in Philadelphia. The Orioles finished ahead of the Spiders in two straight seasons, with Cleveland taking second.

Politics interested McAleer as well. Local media promoted the outfielder as a possible independent Republican candidate for mayor of Youngstown.

Then came a purchase by the Spiders' owners, who bought the St. Louis Browns franchise. Staying in Cleveland was McAleer's choice, and McAleer left baseball for a while. The Spiders lost many of their experienced players and collapsed. Bill James noted that weak crowds forced cancellations of home dates, so the team spent the final two months of that season on the road. No major league team had ever posted a worse record percentage-wise.

Managing cleveland

McAleer came back in 1900 to lead the Cleveland Lake Shores as both player and manager, and the club played at the minor league level in the young American League. The franchise earned a promotion to the majors by 1901 and took the name Blues, borrowed from a National League team of the 1870s and 1880s. Chicago's White Sox beat the Blues in their big league debut. A tense moment arrived in July during a game against Detroit. Tigers manager Tommy Burns feared an angry crowd might harm umpire Joe Cantillon, so Burns agreed to forfeit. McAleer countered by agreeing to go on with a reserve umpire. The Blues ended in seventh place among eight teams. McAleer took part in just three games that year.

Building the American League

Ban Johnson started the American League in 1900 as a direct rival to the established National League. McAleer, a close friend of both Johnson and Charles Comiskey, aided the new circuit by recruiting numerous experienced National League players. McAleer sat out of professional play entirely from 1903 to 1906, and the final major league appearance came in 1907.

The St. louis Browns

McAleer brought Jesse Burkett and Bobby Wallace, both future Hall of Famers, to St. Louis. The Browns finished second in 1902. From 1903 through 1907, though, fifth or sixth was the best they managed. They recovered in 1908, nearly reached first and ended fourth. The club landed in seventh place in 1909, and when the season closed it fired McAleer. Robert L. Hedges, who made carriages in Cincinnati and owned the team, hired the tougher Jack O'Connor as the replacement. The league expelled O'Connor in 1910 for trying to influence the batting title race.

Later years and legacy

Shortly after leaving the dugout, McAleer bought a large stake in the Boston Red Sox, yet the baseball career ended abruptly. A falling out with longtime friend Ban Johnson led McAleer to sell the Red Sox shares and cut ties with the majors. The split and the sudden exit hurt McAleer's reputation, and few people acknowledged the contributions. McAleer is now chiefly remembered for starting the custom of inviting the President of the United States to throw the season's first ball.

Sources