• NFL
  • Running back
  • Career complete

Don Nottingham

Baltimore Colts · Miami Dolphins · 1971 to 1977

Player card. No licensed photo yet.

  • College: Kent State
DN
Don NottinghamNFL · Running back

Fact card

Position
Running back
Teams
Baltimore Colts, Miami Dolphins
Career
1971 to 1977
7
NFL seasons
2
Teams

Rushing yards by season

Baltimore ColtsMiami Dolphins

Each bar is one season, colored by team.

03597181971, Baltimore Colts: 38819711972, Baltimore Colts: 46619721973, Baltimore Colts: 11819731973, Miami Dolphins: 13419731974, Miami Dolphins: 27319741975, Miami Dolphins: 71871819751976, Miami Dolphins: 18519761977, Miami Dolphins: 2141977
Rushing touchdowns

By season, career high marked

06121971, Baltimore Colts: 519711972, Baltimore Colts: 319721973, Baltimore Colts: 119731973, Miami Dolphins: 019731974, Miami Dolphins: 819741975, Miami Dolphins: 121219751976, Miami Dolphins: 319761977, Miami Dolphins: 21977
Receptions

By season, career high marked

012.5251971, Baltimore Colts: 1519711972, Baltimore Colts: 252519721973, Baltimore Colts: 219731973, Miami Dolphins: 119731974, Miami Dolphins: 319741975, Miami Dolphins: 919751976, Miami Dolphins: 419761977, Miami Dolphins: 81977

Season by season

Regular season. Bold numbers with a red dot mark career highs.

Don Nottingham season-by-season statistics
GeneralRushingReceiving
SeasonTeamGamesCarriesRush YdsRush AvgRush LongRush TDCatchesRec YdsRec Avg
1971Baltimore Colts14953884.13651588·
1972Baltimore Colts141234663.825325191·
1973Baltimore Colts3281184.2201210·
1973Miami Dolphins11241345.630011616.0
1974Miami Dolphins14662734.1248340·
1975Miami Dolphins141687184.35612966·
1976Miami Dolphins14631852.9133433·
1977Miami Dolphins14442144.9132858·

More stats: Fumbles, Returns

Don Nottingham additional statistics
FumblesReturns
SeasonTeamFum LostKick ret.Ret YdsRet AvgRet Long
1971Baltimore Colts·····
1972Baltimore Colts··38··
1973Baltimore Colts··17··
1973Miami Dolphins·····
1974Miami Dolphins·····
1975Miami Dolphins0·8026.727
1976Miami Dolphins··107··
1977Miami Dolphins·236··

Career timeline

Team stints by year.

  1. Baltimore Colts1971 to 1973
  2. Miami Dolphins1973 to 1977
19711977
  • Baltimore Colts 3 seasons
  • Miami Dolphins 5 seasons

Career story

Early life and college

Don Nottingham was born on June 28, 1949, and played college football at Kent State. A running back listed at 5-10 and 210 pounds, he played 7 NFL seasons with the Baltimore Colts and Miami Dolphins.

Baltimore Colts

In 1971, Nottingham played 14 games for the Colts and carried 95 times for 388 yards and 5 touchdowns. He averaged 4.1 yards per carry, with a long run of 36 yards, and caught 15 passes for 88 yards.

He played 14 games for Baltimore again in 1972, rushing 123 times for 466 yards and 3 touchdowns. His rushing average was 3.8 yards, and his longest run covered 25 yards. Nottingham also caught 25 passes for 191 yards and returned 2 kicks for 38 yards.

Baltimore and Miami

Nottingham played for both the Colts and Dolphins in 1973. In 3 games with Baltimore, he rushed 28 times for 118 yards and 1 touchdown, averaging 4.2 yards per carry with a long run of 20 yards. He also caught 2 passes for 10 yards.

In 11 games with Miami that season, he carried 24 times for 134 yards. He averaged 5.6 yards per carry, with a long run of 30 yards, and caught 1 pass for 16 yards.

Miami Dolphins

Nottingham played 14 games for Miami in 1974, rushing 66 times for 273 yards and 8 touchdowns. He averaged 4.1 yards per carry, with a long run of 24 yards, and caught 3 passes for 40 yards.

In 1975, he appeared in 14 games and rushed 168 times for 718 yards and 12 touchdowns. He averaged 4.3 yards per carry and had a long run of 56 yards. Nottingham also caught 9 passes for 66 yards and returned 3 kicks for 80 yards, averaging 26.7 yards with a long return of 27 yards.

Final seasons

In 1976, Nottingham played 14 games for the Dolphins, carrying 63 times for 185 yards and 3 touchdowns. He averaged 2.9 yards per carry, with a long run of 13 yards, caught 4 passes for 33 yards and returned 6 kicks for 107 yards.

His final season came in 1977, when he played 14 games for Miami. He rushed 44 times for 214 yards and 2 touchdowns, averaging 4.9 yards with a long run of 13 yards. He caught 8 passes for 58 yards and returned 2 kicks for 36 yards.

The teams around him

Baltimore Colts

The Baltimore Colts used Nottingham in 14 games in 1971, a season in which the club went 10-4, finished second in the AFC East and won one playoff game before losing the AFC championship to the Dolphins, 21-0,, with Don McCafferty as head coach. Carroll Rosenbloom owned the Colts at the time. On Nottingham's side of the ball, the 1971 Colts scored 313 points (tied for fifth most of 26); the defense allowed 140 (second fewest). In 1972 he played 14 games for the Colts, who went 5-9, finished third in the AFC East and missed the playoffs. The Colts scored 235 points in 1972, seventh fewest among 26 teams, while giving up 252. In 1973 he played 3 games for the Colts, who went 4-10 and missed the playoffs under head coach Howard Schnellenberger. The 1973 offense scored 226 points, tied for seventh fewest of 26 teams, and the defense allowed 341 (sixth most).

Miami Dolphins

In 1973, Nottingham appeared in 11 games for the Miami Dolphins, a team that went 12-2, finished first in the AFC East and won Super Bowl VIII over the Vikings, 24-7,, with Don Shula as head coach. Joe Robbie owned the club that year. The 1973 Dolphins were a middle-of-the-pack team on the scoreboard, putting up 343 points (fifth most of 26) and allowing 150 (the fewest). In 1974 he played 14 games for the Dolphins, who went 11-3, finished first in the AFC East and lost the divisional playoffs to the Raiders, 28-26,, again under Don Shula. On his side of the ball, the 1974 Dolphins put up 327 points (third most in a 26-team league) and allowed 216. His third season with the Dolphins, 1975, brought 14 games for a team that went 10-4, finished second in the AFC East and missed the playoffs, again under Don Shula. The Dolphins scored 357 points in 1975, sixth most among 26 teams, while giving up 222. His fourth season with the Dolphins, 1976, brought 14 games for a team that went 6-8, finished third in the AFC East and missed the playoffs, again under Don Shula. The 1976 offense scored 263 points, 14th fewest of 28 teams, and the defense allowed 264 (14th most). In 1977 he played 14 games for the Dolphins, who went 10-4, finished second in the AFC East and missed the playoffs, again under Don Shula. On his side of the ball, the 1977 Dolphins put up 313 points (third most in a 28-team league) and allowed 197.

His head coach with the Dolphins, Don Shula, had been an NFL player himself, and his playing career has its own profile here.

Before he arrived and after he left

The Colts had finished 11-2-1 in 1970, the year before Nottingham arrived, and went 10-4 in 1971 with him on the roster (one fewer win). Nottingham's last Colts season, 1973, ended 4-10, and the year after Nottingham left, the club went 2-12. The Dolphins had finished 14-0 in 1972, the year before Nottingham arrived, and went 12-2 in 1973 with him on the roster (2 fewer wins). By 1977, Nottingham's final year there, the Dolphins were 10-4; they went 11-5 the season after he left.

School and draft class

Nottingham's high school was Ravenna High School.

On the roster

At running back he was not alone: Norm Bulaich and Sam Havrilak were also running backs on the Baltimore Colts in 1971, 1972 and 1973. Teammates from those seasons with their own profiles on this site include Garo Yepremian, a kicker; Dick Anderson, a safety; Nat Moore, a wide receiver; and Rick Volk, a free safety.

Sources and credits

Facts checked November 10, 2026. Statistics are regular season unless marked. Spot an error? Send a correction.

Player card artwork is original. Team colors are used for charts only; no team logos are shown.

Correct or claim this profile