Regular season. Bold numbers with a red dot mark career highs.
Jim Mutscheller season-by-season statistics
Season
Team
Games
1954
Baltimore Colts
12
1955
Baltimore Colts
12
1956
Baltimore Colts
12
1957
Baltimore Colts
12
1958
Baltimore Colts
12
1959
Baltimore Colts
12
1960
Baltimore Colts
11
1961
Baltimore Colts
12
More stats: Receiving, Fumbles
Jim Mutscheller additional statistics
Receiving
Fumbles
Season
Team
Catches
Fumbles
Fum Lost
1954
Baltimore Colts
1
0
0
1955
Baltimore Colts
33
0
0
1956
Baltimore Colts
44
1
0
1957
Baltimore Colts
32
1
0
1958
Baltimore Colts
28
·
·
1959
Baltimore Colts
44
2
0
1960
Baltimore Colts
18
·
·
1961
Baltimore Colts
20
·
·
Career timeline
Team stints by year.
Baltimore Colts1954 to 1961
19541961
Career story
Overview
Jim Mutscheller was an end who played eight seasons in the NFL, from 1954 through 1961, all of them with the Baltimore Colts. He stood 6-1 and weighed 205 pounds. He played his college football at the University of Notre Dame before turning to professional football.
First seasons with the Baltimore Colts
Mutscheller opened his career in 1954 and played 12 games. He caught one pass that year, a 49-yard reception, and he also recovered one opponent fumble.
His production grew quickly in 1955, when he caught 33 passes for 518 yards and seven touchdowns. He averaged 15.7 yards per catch, and his longest reception went for 48 yards.
Best seasons
In 1956 Mutscheller caught 44 passes for 715 yards and six touchdowns, the highest yardage total of his eight seasons. He averaged 16.2 yards per catch, with a longest reception of 53 yards.
His 1957 season produced 32 catches for 558 yards and eight touchdowns, an average of 17.4 yards per catch, including a 66-yard reception. In 1958 he had 28 catches for 504 yards and seven touchdowns, averaging 18 yards per catch with a longest reception of 54 yards.
In 1959 he matched his 1956 reception total with 44 catches for 699 yards and eight touchdowns. He averaged 15.9 yards per catch that season, and his longest reception went for 40 yards. His eight touchdowns in both 1957 and 1959 were the most he scored in a single season.
Final seasons
His last two seasons produced fewer catches. In 1960 he caught 18 passes for 271 yards and two touchdowns in 11 games, averaging 15.1 yards per catch with a longest reception of 43 yards.
In 1961, his final season, he caught 20 passes for 370 yards and two touchdowns in 12 games. He averaged 18.5 yards per catch, and his longest reception went for 45 yards.
Durability and ball security
Mutscheller played 12 games in every season of his career except 1960, when he played 11. He fumbled once in 1956, once in 1957 and twice in 1959, and he did not lose any of those fumbles.
The teams around him
Baltimore Colts
In 1954, Mutscheller appeared in 12 games for the Baltimore Colts, a team that went 3-9, finished sixth in the NFL Western and missed the playoffs in Weeb Ewbank's first season as head coach, after Keith Molesworth had run the team in 1953. Ownership sat with Carroll Rosenbloom in 1954. Points were hard to come by for Mutscheller's 1954 Colts offense: 131 total, the fewest of 12 teams. His second season with the Colts, 1955, brought 12 games for a team that went 5-6-1, finished fourth in the NFL Western and missed the playoffs, again under Weeb Ewbank. That 1955 team finished with 214 points for and 239 against, second fewest and sixth fewest in a 12-team league. His third season with the Colts, 1956, brought 12 games for a team that went 5-7, finished fourth in the NFL Western and missed the playoffs, again under Weeb Ewbank. The 1956 Colts produced 270 points, fourth most among 12 teams, and gave up 322. His fourth season with the Colts, 1957, brought 12 games for a team that went 7-5, finished third in the NFL Western and missed the playoffs, again under Weeb Ewbank. In 1957 the Colts scored 303 points (second most of 12) and allowed 235 (fifth most). In 1958 he played 12 games for the Colts, who went 9-3, finished first in the NFL Western and won the NFL Championship over the Giants, 23-17,, again under Weeb Ewbank. That 1958 team finished with 381 points for and 203 against, the most and second fewest in a 12-team league. In 1959 he played 12 games for the Colts, who went 9-3, finished first in the NFL Western and won the NFL Championship over the Giants, 31-16,, again under Weeb Ewbank. The 1959 Colts produced 374 points, the most among 12 teams, and gave up 251. In 1960 he played 11 games for the Colts, who went 6-6, finished fourth in the NFL Western and missed the playoffs, again under Weeb Ewbank. In 1960 the Colts scored 288 points (tied for fourth most of 13) and allowed 234 (sixth fewest). His eighth season with the Colts, 1961, brought 12 games for a team that went 8-6 and missed the playoffs, again under Weeb Ewbank. That 1961 team finished with 302 points for and 307 against, seventh most and fifth most in a 14-team league.
Before he arrived and after he left
The season before Mutscheller reached the Colts, 1953, the team went 3-9; his first year there ended 3-9, the same number of wins. By 1961, Mutscheller's final year there, the Colts were 8-6; they went 7-7 the season after he left.