• NFL
  • Defensive back
  • Career complete

Andy Nelson

Baltimore Colts · New York Giants · 1957 to 1964

  • College: Memphis
Andy Nelson
Andy NelsonNFL · Defensive back

Fact card

Position
Defensive back
Teams
Baltimore Colts, New York Giants
Career
1957 to 1964

Photo: Dottie White, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

33
Career interceptions
8
NFL seasons
2
Teams

Total tackles by season

Baltimore ColtsNew York Giants
Interceptions

By season, career high marked

0481957, Baltimore Colts: 519571958, Baltimore Colts: 8819581959, Baltimore Colts: 619591960, Baltimore Colts: 619601962, Baltimore Colts: 419621963, Baltimore Colts: 319631964, New York Giants: 11964

Season by season

Regular season. Bold numbers with a red dot mark career highs.

Andy Nelson season-by-season statistics
GeneralDefense
SeasonTeamGamesTacklesSoloAssistedSacksIntInt yardsForced fum.Fum. rec.Int longInt avgInt TDFum. TD
1957Baltimore Colts12····529··135.8··
1958Baltimore Colts12····8199·26924.9·0
1959Baltimore Colts12····633·1335.5·0
1960Baltimore Colts12····647··227.8··
1961Baltimore Colts140000.0··0·····
1962Baltimore Colts14····420··105.0··
1963Baltimore Colts13····337··2612.3··
1964New York Giants14····113··1313.00·
CareerAll teams·····33·······

More stats: Fumbles, Returns

Andy Nelson additional statistics
FumblesReturns
SeasonTeamFumblesFum LostPunt ret.Ret YdsRet AvgRet LongPR TD
1957Baltimore Colts·······
1958Baltimore Colts00·····
1959Baltimore Colts00·····
1960Baltimore Colts··310.310
1961Baltimore Colts··4194.8120
1962Baltimore Colts1022211.0140
1963Baltimore Colts·······
1964New York Giants·······

Career timeline

Team stints by year.

  1. Baltimore Colts1957 to 1963
  2. New York Giants1964
19571964
  • Baltimore Colts 7 seasons
  • New York Giants 1 season

Career story

College and NFL career

Andy Nelson played college football at Memphis before beginning an NFL career as a defensive back. Listed at 6-1 and 180 pounds, he played 8 seasons, from 1957 through 1964.

Nelson spent his first seasons with the Baltimore Colts, playing for the team from 1957 through 1963. He finished his career with the New York Giants in 1964.

Early seasons in Baltimore

In 1957, Nelson played 12 games for Baltimore and intercepted 5 passes. He returned those interceptions for 29 yards, averaging 5.8 yards per return, with a long of 13 yards.

Nelson played 12 games in 1958 and recorded 8 interceptions for 199 yards and 1 touchdown. He averaged 24.9 yards per interception return, with a long of 69 yards, and recovered 2 opponent fumbles.

In 1959, he had 6 interceptions for 33 yards and 1 touchdown in 12 games. His interception returns averaged 5.5 yards, with a long of 33, and he recovered 1 opponent fumble.

Later Colts seasons

Nelson played 12 games for the Colts in 1960 and intercepted 6 passes for 47 yards, averaging 7.8 yards with a long of 22. He also returned 3 punts for 1 yard, with a 0.3 average and a long of 1.

In 1961, he appeared in 14 games and returned 4 punts for 19 yards. He averaged 4.8 yards per punt return, with a long of 12.

Nelson played 14 games in 1962, recording 4 interceptions for 20 yards. His interception returns averaged 5 yards, with a long of 10. He also returned 2 punts for 22 yards, averaging 11 yards with a long of 14, and had 1 fumble.

In his final Baltimore season in 1963, Nelson played 13 games and had 3 interceptions for 37 yards and 1 touchdown. He averaged 12.3 yards per interception return, with a long of 26.

New York and career totals

Nelson played 14 games for the New York Giants in 1964. He intercepted 1 pass and returned it for 13 yards, giving him an interception return average and long of 13 yards.

Over his career, Nelson played 103 games and recorded 33 interceptions for 378 yards and 3 touchdowns. His interception returns averaged 11.5 yards, with a long of 69. He also returned 9 punts for 42 yards, averaging 4.7 yards with a long of 14, and recovered 3 opponent fumbles.

The teams around him

Baltimore Colts

Nelson's first season with the Baltimore Colts, 1957, meant 12 games for a club that went 7-5, finished third in the NFL Western and missed the playoffs under head coach Weeb Ewbank. Ownership sat with Carroll Rosenbloom in 1957. Nelson's defensive group in 1957 allowed 235 points (fifth most of 12), while the offense scored 303 (second most). In 1958 he played 12 games for the Colts, who went 9-3, finished first in the NFL Western and won the NFL Championship over the Giants, 23-17,, again under Weeb Ewbank. On his side of the ball, the 1958 Colts gave up 203 points (second fewest in a 12-team league); the offense scored 381 (the most). His third season with the Colts, 1959, brought 12 games for a team that went 9-3, finished first in the NFL Western and won the NFL Championship over the Giants, 31-16,, again under Weeb Ewbank. Opponents scored 251 points against the 1959 Colts, sixth most among 12 teams, and the offense answered with 374. In 1960 he played 12 games for the Colts, who went 6-6, finished fourth in the NFL Western and missed the playoffs, again under Weeb Ewbank. The 1960 defense allowed 234 points, sixth fewest of 13 teams, while the offense put up 288. His fifth season with the Colts, 1961, brought 14 games for a team that went 8-6 and missed the playoffs, again under Weeb Ewbank. On his side of the ball, the 1961 Colts gave up 307 points (fifth most in a 14-team league); the offense scored 302 (seventh most). In 1962 he played 14 games for the Colts, who went 7-7, finished fourth in the NFL Western and missed the playoffs, again under Weeb Ewbank. Opponents scored 288 points against the 1962 Colts, sixth fewest among 14 teams, and the offense answered with 293. His seventh season with the Colts, 1963, brought 13 games for a team that went 8-6, finished third in the NFL Western and missed the playoffs in Don Shula's first season as head coach, after Weeb Ewbank had run the team in 1962. The 1963 defense allowed 285 points, seventh fewest of 14 teams, while the offense put up 316.

New York Giants

In 1964, Nelson appeared in 14 games for the New York Giants, a team that went 2-10-2, finished seventh in the NFL Eastern and missed the playoffs, with Allie Sherman as head coach. Ownership sat with Jack Mara and Wellington Mara in 1964. Points came easily against Nelson's Giants defense in 1964: 399 allowed, the most of 14 teams.

His head coach with the Colts, Don Shula, had been an NFL player himself, and his playing career has its own profile here.

Before he arrived and after he left

The Colts had finished 5-7 in 1956, the year before Nelson arrived, and went 7-5 in 1957 with him on the roster (2 more wins). Nelson's last Colts season, 1963, ended 8-6, and the year after Nelson left, the club went 12-2. The season before Nelson reached the Giants, 1963, the team went 11-3; his first year there ended 2-10-2, 9 fewer wins.

On the roster

At defensive back he was not alone: Jim Welch and Carl Taseff were also defensive backs on the Baltimore Colts in 1957, 1958 and 1959. Teammates from those seasons with their own profiles on this site include Don Shinnick, a linebacker; Johnny Unitas, a quarterback; Raymond Berry, a wide receiver; and Lenny Moore, a running back.

Sources and credits

Facts checked November 10, 2026. Statistics are regular season unless marked. Spot an error? Send a correction.

Photo: Dottie White, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons. Team colors are used for charts only; no team logos are shown.

Correct or claim this profile