• NFL
  • Offensive tackle
  • Career complete

Paul Costa

Buffalo Bills · 1965 to 1972

Player card. No licensed photo yet.

  • College: Notre Dame
PC
Paul CostaNFL · Offensive tackle

Fact card

Position
Offensive tackle
Teams
Buffalo Bills
Career
1965 to 1972
8
NFL seasons
1
Team

Games played by season

Buffalo Bills

Each bar is one season, colored by team.

07141965, Buffalo Bills: 1019651966, Buffalo Bills: 141419661967, Buffalo Bills: 141419671968, Buffalo Bills: 141419681969, Buffalo Bills: 141419691970, Buffalo Bills: 141419701971, Buffalo Bills: 1119711972, Buffalo Bills: 91972

Season by season

Regular season. Bold numbers with a red dot mark career highs.

Paul Costa season-by-season statistics
SeasonTeamGames
1965Buffalo Bills10
1966Buffalo Bills14
1967Buffalo Bills14
1968Buffalo Bills14
1969Buffalo Bills14
1970Buffalo Bills14
1971Buffalo Bills11
1972Buffalo Bills9

More stats: Rushing, Receiving, Fumbles, Returns

Paul Costa additional statistics
RushingReceivingFumblesReturns
SeasonTeamCarriesRush YdsRush AvgRush LongRush TDCatchesRec YdsRec AvgRec LongRec TDFumblesFum LostKick ret.Ret YdsRet AvgRet LongRet TD
1965Buffalo Bills··········1······
1966Buffalo Bills·····2740014.850300·····
1967Buffalo Bills·····3972618.66322······
1968Buffalo Bills2115.561·······56813.6330
1969Buffalo Bills·················
1970Buffalo Bills·················
1971Buffalo Bills·················
1972Buffalo Bills·················

Career timeline

Team stints by year.

  1. Buffalo Bills1965 to 1972
19651972

Career story

Overview

Paul Costa was an offensive tackle who played eight professional seasons with the Buffalo Bills, from 1965 through 1972. He stood 6-6 and weighed 268 pounds. He played his college football at Notre Dame before beginning his pro career in Buffalo, and he never played for another franchise.

The first seasons, 1965 and 1966

Costa began his career in 1965, when the Buffalo Bills played in the American Football League. He appeared in 10 games that year and caught 21 passes for 401 yards, an average of 19.1 yards per catch, with a longest reception of 46 yards. He also fumbled once that season.

In 1966 he played 14 games and caught 27 passes for 400 yards and three touchdowns. His average was 14.8 yards per catch, and his longest reception went for 50 yards.

Peak production, 1967 and 1968

Costa's busiest receiving year came in 1967. In 14 games he caught 39 passes for 726 yards and two touchdowns, averaging 18.6 yards per catch. His longest reception that season covered 63 yards. He fumbled twice that year.

In 1968 he again played 14 games. He caught 15 passes for 172 yards and a touchdown, with a longest catch of 27 yards. He also carried the ball twice for 11 yards, an average of 5.5 yards, with a longest run of six yards, and scored one rushing touchdown. On special teams he returned five kicks for 68 yards, an average of 13.6 yards, with a longest return of 33 yards.

The merger years, 1969 to 1972

Costa played 14 games in 1969, the final AFL season. The 1970 merger brought the Bills into the National Football League, and he again appeared in 14 games that year. His workload then eased, with 11 games in 1971 and nine in 1972, the last season of his career.

Career summary

Costa spent all eight seasons, 1965 through 1972, with the Buffalo Bills. He played in both the American Football League and the AFL and the NFL without changing teams, and he was a regular on the field for a full 14-game schedule in each year from 1966 through 1970.

The teams around him

Buffalo Bills

Costa played 10 games for the Buffalo Bills in 1965, on a roster that went 10-3-1, finished first in the AFL Eastern and won the AFL Championship over the Chargers, 23-0,, with Lou Saban as head coach. Ralph Wilson owned the club that year. Scoring was the strength of Costa's 1965 Bills team, with 313 points (third most of 8). In 1966 he played 14 games for the Bills, who went 9-4-1, finished first in the AFL Eastern and lost the AFL championship to the Chiefs, 31-7, in Joe Collier's first season as head coach, after Lou Saban had run the team in 1965. The Bills scored 358 points in 1966, second most among 9 teams, while giving up 255. In 1967 he played 14 games for the Bills, who went 4-10, finished third in the AFL Eastern and missed the playoffs, again under Joe Collier. The 1967 offense scored 237 points, second fewest of 9 teams, and the defense allowed 285 (fourth fewest). His fourth season with the Bills, 1968, brought 14 games for a team that went 1-12-1, finished fifth in the AFL Eastern and missed the playoffs. On his side of the ball, the 1968 Bills put up 199 points (the fewest in a 10-team league) and allowed 367. In 1969 he played 14 games for the Bills, who went 4-10, finished fourth in the AFL Eastern and missed the playoffs under head coach John Rauch. The Bills scored 230 points in 1969, the fewest among 10 teams, while giving up 359. His sixth season with the Bills, 1970, brought 14 games for a team that went 3-10-1, finished fourth in the AFC East and missed the playoffs, again under John Rauch. The 1970 offense scored 204 points, fourth fewest of 26 teams, and the defense allowed 337 (fourth most). In 1971 he played 11 games for the Bills, who went 1-13, finished fifth in the AFC East and missed the playoffs in Harvey Johnson's first season as head coach, after John Rauch had run the team in 1970. On his side of the ball, the 1971 Bills put up 184 points (the fewest in a 26-team league) and allowed 394. In 1972 he played 9 games for the Bills, who went 4-9-1, finished fourth in the AFC East and missed the playoffs in Lou Saban's first season as head coach, after Harvey Johnson had run the team in 1971. The Bills scored 257 points in 1972, eighth fewest among 26 teams, while giving up 377.

His head coach with the Bills, John Rauch, had been an NFL player himself, and his playing career has its own profile here.

Before he arrived and after he left

The season before Costa reached the Bills, 1964, the team went 12-2; his first year there ended 10-3-1, 2 fewer wins. By 1972, Costa's final year there, the Bills were 4-9-1; they went 9-5 the season after he left.

On the roster

He shared a locker room with Mike Stratton, an outside linebacker; John Pitts, a safety; Harry Jacobs, a middle linebacker; and George Saimes, a safety.

Sources and credits

Facts checked November 10, 2026. Statistics are regular season unless marked. Spot an error? Send a correction.

Player card artwork is original. Team colors are used for charts only; no team logos are shown.

Correct or claim this profile